‘Furious’ Episode 5: Cat Meets Mouse

2026-08-11 22:30:00 • 1:02:52

-

Hey, I just Venmo Deferent.

0:01

Nice.

0:02

Now I can instantly spend it whether I'm checking out online with Venmo,

0:05

or using the Venmo Devacore.

0:07

Same more.

0:08

More exactly, because the more you do with Venmo, the more you get.

0:12

Like earning up to 5% cash back with Venmo Stash on a bundle of brains.

0:16

So, order more pizza.

0:18

The math demands it.

0:19

Get the Venmo Devacore.

0:21

Venmo Stash bundle terms and exclusions apply.

0:23

See terms of Venmo.me slash dash terms.

0:25

Venmo check out not available with all merchants.

0:27

Venmo master cart is issued by the Bencore Bank NA.

0:48

Hello, welcome back to the prestige TV podcast,

0:51

sweetheart. I'm Dwayna Robinson.

0:52

I am Marta Dresnik and I love salad.

0:56

From Moni, we missed you.

0:58

I missed you. I missed being on the show.

1:00

I missed the start of Furious and I am very upset about it.

1:03

This is a wonderful show.

1:04

Are you furious about it?

1:06

No, not quite to that level, but look,

1:08

you've already forgotten the rules of yes and on the podcast.

1:12

On the contrary, I'm not here to step on women's rage.

1:14

Oh, I'm acknowledging the boundary and backing up respectfully.

1:20

All right, we're here to cover Furious,

1:22

the Hulu show.

1:24

Would you could also watch on Disney,

1:25

some light family fare on Disney plus if you prefer.

1:30

We covered episodes one through four.

1:33

Our paliessi salad stepped in for Rob to cover that last week.

1:37

That was a fairly chaotic podcast, not just because...

1:40

It was a delight for my podcast.

1:41

Oh, it's a delight.

1:42

Always.

1:43

Time with Yasi is always a delight.

1:45

Time with Joanna, not organizing her thoughts over the course of four episodes.

1:49

Chaotic.

1:50

Oh, come on, come on.

1:51

We're covering one episode today.

1:52

It does simplify things a little bit.

1:54

A much clearer sort of thing.

1:55

So up through episode five of Furious,

1:58

pick a sticker is what it's called if you've not watched up through episode five,

2:01

I would recommend you do that because there are several revelations,

2:04

twists and turns inside of this episode.

2:06

We lost yet another beloved character actor.

2:10

And before we get into any of that,

2:13

we do some emails, but I want to just sort of off the top.

2:15

Rob, you were a jet setting around Europe.

2:18

That was.

2:20

But still answering emails because work-life balance alludes us all.

2:24

Who knows it?

2:25

And I was like, Rob, Furious, it's a show we should cover.

2:30

And then you had to come back and sort of like cram it because you just got back.

2:33

Had to.

2:35

But first of all, you were like, if you like the show, I'll like the show.

2:38

What a compliment.

2:39

Secondly, did you like the show?

2:40

Absolutely.

2:41

I did.

2:42

I mean, I think this is like a pretty remarkable piece of television to be honest.

2:46

It is so expertly drawn in terms of the lead characters, especially.

2:50

So well balanced.

2:52

I just like that they don't make anyone be one thing.

2:55

Like everyone is super messy and they're living in a fucked up world with

2:58

fucked up systems and making compromises constantly.

3:01

I mean, that's our kind of show.

3:02

Yeah, absolutely.

3:04

Do you support the character, Catherine Grace, killing that shelter lady?

3:11

I thought you were going to say just inter-emerders more generally.

3:13

Yeah, more generally, sure.

3:14

But may specifically shelter lady, that seems to be the one that people are a little

3:19

perturbed that I support it.

3:20

I don't really, I don't support that.

3:22

No, no.

3:23

But the other murder.

3:25

The dudes who were involved in trafficking children.

3:30

Yeah.

3:31

See, this backs me into a corner, someone who is famously both anti-murder

3:35

and anti-human trafficking.

3:36

Who might to support?

3:38

Yeah, well, which one are you more anti?

3:40

I think I probably look the human trafficking is not a good look.

3:43

It's not good for anybody.

3:44

And that may sound glib us talking about it in this way.

3:48

But I feel like we have some license, given the weird tonality that you and Diasi talked about

3:52

in the first four episodes of this show, it is a miracle that they are able to pull off

3:56

something this heavy consistently with a grim sense of humor about it while kind of poking at

4:03

the characters.

4:03

And I think the victims themselves being fleshed out into actual human beings who are not simply

4:09

defined as this one thing all the time.

4:11

I find it very, like, engrossing, perturbing, but also entertaining.

4:17

Like, this show, to me, does not feel like a slog.

4:20

And you know, I, again, Diasi and I talked about this,

4:24

but I haven't encountered some people who say like, I don't, you know,

4:27

I'm not emotionally connected to these characters.

4:29

That's not my experience at all with this show.

4:31

I am sort of like emotionally all the way in on both sides.

4:34

All three of our furious women that are sort of leading this show,

4:38

I am emotionally bought into all of them, deeply emotionally bought into Scoom McNairy

4:44

and very worried about him constantly.

4:46

So this was an odd week for him.

4:47

Yeah, don't, don't share this information with Marshall, right?

4:51

There's just, there's one thing in life you can simply not do.

4:54

Yeah.

4:55

And it's till the abuse of guy that the woman he battered is now into in a very different way.

5:00

Yeah.

5:01

Being knocked around a little bit on her own terms.

5:03

What, what was the motivation for sharing?

5:05

I simply don't know.

5:06

I was, I was so baffled by it.

5:07

I was like, did we miss a wink, wink sort of conversation like the one Danny Kelly has

5:12

with Nora and the elevator of like, I can't tell you what to do.

5:16

My guy.

5:16

Yeah.

5:17

And it was like, did like Alice somehow engineer this?

5:20

Was she pulling a puppet string?

5:22

But there's simply no explanation for it.

5:23

We, we will go more orderly through the episode.

5:25

Here, here's my best assessment that I could possibly make for our guy, Danny Kelly,

5:31

not to be confused with the ringer zone Danny Kelly and his bizarre choice to share this

5:36

information with Marshall.

5:37

Um, which is that, you know, he's like, hey, there's a house, the Jersey Shore, where I definitely

5:44

am going to go there and I'm definitely going to survive the season and make it to the house

5:47

of the Jersey Shore.

5:48

Don't worry about it.

5:49

Do you want to come with me and she is sort of like a freak out about it, right?

5:52

Yes.

5:53

And then he, when he's having that conversation with Marshall, he's like, you know, get a dream

5:59

journal, go to therapy, work on yourself.

6:01

She still loves you.

6:02

So my, like, the line that I was drawing from her turning down seemingly or at least

6:08

freaking out about the idea of the trip to the Jersey Shore, I want to come back to her

6:12

reaction to that.

6:13

And then, um, and then him sort of telling Marshall this stuff, you know, in a way that's

6:18

like, get your shit together.

6:19

Yeah.

6:20

And be worthy of her because I guess the season love with you.

6:24

Maybe there's some way to redeem you so she can have what she wants because Danny

6:27

Kelly is the most self-sacrificing guy that has ever existed in fiction.

6:32

Well, he has Irish so presumably, maybe not presumably, but could be Catholic.

6:36

Do you, um, is there more Irish name than Danny Kelly?

6:39

There's not.

6:40

Okay.

6:41

Potato accusations are fair.

6:42

Do you, do you like, do I ship it?

6:45

No.

6:46

I mean, yeah, I do.

6:47

I started my turn Marshall.

6:48

I'm like, no, I don't.

6:49

No, no, no, but do you buy that as sort of like his motivation for that conversation

6:54

and why he might make this really weird choice to share this information with him?

6:59

Just try to scare him straight because from where I'm sitting at home, there's no, there's

7:06

no redemption for Marshall.

7:07

But if Danny Kelly is like, well, she's going to be in love with you anyway.

7:11

Maybe you can turn your shit around and be the kind of guy who deserves her.

7:16

Do you know?

7:17

I think Danny Kelly as well as anybody on this show.

7:20

Yeah.

7:21

We're just going to refer him by his phone because he is a Danny Kelly.

7:24

Absolutely.

7:25

And C's Alice as somebody whose wires are crossed all the time who understandably given

7:30

her circumstances and what she's been through just like cannot separate any of these massive

7:34

gravitational forces in her life, especially as they concern Marshall.

7:37

And so yeah, it's like acknowledging some of the inevitability of the situation, not

7:41

just like, oh, she's still in love with you.

7:43

But we learn over the course of these last couple episodes.

7:45

I mean, they've had a lifetime of kind of connection and relationship and often on or

7:50

whatever it was leading up to all of the stuff that is causing separation and the violence

7:56

that he inflicted upon her.

7:57

And so it's like, for one, like of all of the characterizations in the show, what they

8:02

have done with Danny is something I don't think I've ever seen before, which is like the

8:06

very specific, like, full-throated, no questions asked support of a victim of violence.

8:12

Yeah.

8:13

But so no questions asked.

8:14

He literally didn't ask any other questions.

8:16

And so like never followed up and never really heard what happened.

8:19

I'm so impressed by the deafness of that idea in conjunction with all of this other insane

8:26

shit and heavy shit that's happening on this show.

8:28

Like they just found like very delicate ways around the edges, even while being a somewhat

8:34

knock you over the head show at times to dig into some of this stuff.

8:38

So like believe women, but don't actually talk to women is that I think that is that

8:42

Danny's approach here.

8:44

The idea of like being so respectful of Alice coming to him when she is ready to do it,

8:51

that it just creates distance between them in the aftermath of all this.

8:54

And so like that, I mean, that's kind of the heartbreaking thing about where they find

8:56

themselves is these two people who are in theory the closest connections either of them

9:01

have certainly at work.

9:02

And yet they're still this kind of gulf they're trying to cross.

9:05

And so much so that Danny has given Marshall the like, I guess get your life together,

9:09

dude, talk.

9:10

Before we get into sort of the episode, slightly beat by beat, I want to hit some emails

9:15

we got.

9:16

We're not doing a cutesy, john T little email for this show just because I think we're

9:21

too far into the serious tone of the show to get cute about it.

9:25

Yeah.

9:25

So that's the choice we've made.

9:27

Maybe a saving grace for us on that.

9:28

But a good decision for once.

9:30

Also, I did promise our producer Kai that I would plug our life show at the top of the

9:35

show.

9:36

I did not do that.

9:37

But this podcast is going up theoretically on Tuesday, August 11th and on Friday, the

9:43

Friday of this week, August 14th, we are doing a live show at the Tel Avars TV Festival.

9:50

1115 a.m. on a Friday.

9:53

Yeah, that's our time.

9:54

It's a curious time for a live show, but that is what we are doing.

9:59

It is when we record many podcasts more or less.

10:02

Oh, yeah.

10:03

So that's our energy.

10:05

That is what we will be bringing to the show on Friday.

10:08

Our plan right now is to do some sort of best of the year so far, but competitive draft

10:14

style, ringer style, unleash Rob's worst friendship instinct style, kind of live show.

10:23

You are who you are, Rob.

10:24

I don't know how to take that.

10:26

I mean, lean into the reputation perhaps.

10:29

I just want to pick the good things in the draft that people get upset for some reason.

10:32

I thought that's what we were doing here.

10:35

Come see us.

10:36

What do you want to say about that?

10:37

You do have to buy a ticket to Tel Avars.

10:39

They have day passes that you can buy.

10:40

So if you want to buy that, you should, you know, come to the whole festival.

10:43

Why not?

10:44

Yes.

10:45

But on Friday, not only are we doing the live show, but later that day, I am hosting a

10:49

my so-called life reunion panel that I am very, very excited about.

10:52

So there's just a lot of great stuff going a lot of great programming going on if you're

10:55

a fan of television, which I presume if you listen to this podcast you are anything

11:00

else you want to say about the live show.

11:01

Well, there's all that great programming, but foremost, we are there.

11:04

And there will be a show.

11:06

There will be best ofs.

11:07

There will be singing.

11:08

There will be dancing.

11:09

Joanna will be a quadruple threat on stage.

11:11

I don't know what the fourth thread is yet, but we're going to figure it out.

11:13

Okay.

11:14

Murderous drafting.

11:15

That's my opinion.

11:16

That is a talent of yours as well.

11:18

Nives out.

11:19

Nives out for drafting.

11:20

Okay.

11:21

So that is what we were doing this Friday.

11:22

You know, come hang out.

11:23

Come see us.

11:24

Please.

11:25

And it is our plan to cover Furious week to week for the rest of the season.

11:28

So that is something we were doing as well.

11:30

We're going to make email check in our listener, Meg on the Danny Kelly front.

11:34

Our listener, Meg says, I don't know what to do with this observation, but the show has

11:37

a plague of what I call girl with two first name syndrome.

11:41

Catherine Grace.

11:42

Danny Kelly.

11:43

Ed George Oliver Charles.

11:45

Yeah.

11:46

Just something, something to watch.

11:48

I don't think that bodes well for Danny Kelly.

11:50

I find those are the people who are getting knocked off.

11:53

I mean, fingers crossed, Ed George.

11:55

I'm not a fan.

11:58

Megan and a number of our listeners wrote in with the theory that the young woman that

12:02

I believe her name is Elena that Catherine was trying to help in the motel who, you know,

12:07

is theoretically is a bell sister.

12:10

Yes.

12:11

A strong theory that that is actually her daughter.

12:13

Oh.

12:14

That the timing works out that that could have been the kid that she in this episode we

12:20

find gave up.

12:22

Yeah.

12:23

So any thoughts about that?

12:24

I honestly hadn't even put that together timeline wise.

12:26

It does make sense.

12:27

And they could also be somewhat distant siblings in the pecking order, you know, not unlike

12:32

the way that Alison, her own sister are kind of like separated by age and didn't really

12:36

grow up together.

12:37

So I could see it, but I'm kind of operating on face that they are actually sisters for

12:42

right now.

12:43

Okay.

12:44

Our listener Ray wrote in to say, I think that the show is great strength so far, showing

12:47

how exhausting it is to be sexualized and are victimized in every single space by nearly

12:52

everyone.

12:53

Catherine is sexualized everywhere she goes.

12:55

And because it's the only thing she's ever been told she's good at, she uses it to

12:59

manipulate and then naturally resents those who fall for it regardless of gender.

13:03

I do worry for sweetie Steve Ray.

13:06

That's the actor who's playing Alden who's fantastic in this episode.

13:11

Save for now, thankfully.

13:12

Yes.

13:13

I was so worried when they walked into the house that he was going to be dead.

13:19

But like that, the fact that you were worried, that's what I'm saying is incredibly powerful.

13:23

Yeah.

13:24

I don't know how that little girl completely that to me was the moment where the show like

13:28

really clicked into place.

13:29

I'm so one is really good.

13:30

But when you get to the girls night with Mira in episode two, simply the idea that this

13:36

girl could actually be in danger is something that the vast majority of TV shows just cannot

13:40

pull off.

13:41

They can't make the threat feel real.

13:42

And that's why she had to kill that woman from the shelter and stick her in the bushes.

13:48

Again, pro murder joke.

13:49

It's going to just the murderous Joanna Robinson really coming on strong.

13:53

But I do think that inside of this episode, when we watch Alice, obviously they're drawing

14:00

lines between Nora and Alice and Catherine and their various flavors of rage and all

14:06

of that.

14:07

But Alice inside of this episode when she lures Marshall to her house and puts on this

14:14

whole act for him and uses language that is very similar to things that Catherine Grace

14:19

said to previous her victims, but also her abusers.

14:25

Yeah.

14:26

The whole thing about owning me.

14:27

Yeah.

14:28

Exactly right.

14:29

That's the moment.

14:30

So I think that this idea of if you're going to treat me like this frail thing and then

14:37

I'm going to pretend to be the frail thing that you've decided to treat me as and then

14:43

that is going to be the thing that sort of bites you is definitely something this show

14:48

was interested in.

14:49

But interesting to watch Alice use these tactics.

14:51

I mean, this is a tale is old is time with any single sort of FBI serial killer show where

14:58

it's just sort of like the agent and the killer and what DNA they have in common and where

15:05

are they moving towards each other or away from each other in terms of their behavior.

15:11

And I think that feeds into this last theme when we got from Catherine as far as I know

15:15

not Catherine Grace.

15:16

Thank goodness.

15:17

I would love to hear your thoughts on the role of law enforcement and all of the moral

15:20

dilemmas that the show is presenting.

15:22

FBI is still law enforcement.

15:24

Yes, Alice is in the company more, but she still works within the system that upholds

15:28

like this whole problem.

15:30

If there is a twist at the end of the show, I hope it's about how the system is corrupt

15:33

and there's no way to dismantle the master's house with the master's tools.

15:37

Alice works really hard throughout the season and because she's brilliant, she gets evidence,

15:41

this is like a prediction that Catherine's making.

15:43

Alice works really hard throughout the season because she's brilliant, she gets evidence

15:45

still because Jay Easton has an in with the FBI or the NYPD, he gets to walk three free.

15:51

So like Catherine is wondering if the end of the season is not, everything is tied up

15:57

with a bow and justice is served, but just a further condemnation of the system that we're

16:02

all operating in.

16:03

I mean, we are five episodes in.

16:06

There is not a bow big enough in the world to tie all this together.

16:09

This is just not going to be a neat ending.

16:10

I don't think the show has any interest in telling a neat story, which is what makes it so

16:14

watchable to this point.

16:16

Yeah.

16:17

Clearly, this is a lot of the focus of Ed George right now as a character is sort of representing

16:21

this larger, protecting the interests of power sort of fixture within the office and

16:27

threatening nor to do it, which by extension, threatens Alice in her position.

16:31

Like the chain of command there and the way everyone is getting squeezed, I think is

16:34

really compelling TV.

16:35

A perfect punchable face from this guy.

16:38

Yeah.

16:39

And I also love that he doesn't seem stupid.

16:42

I think that there are versions of this character and other shows where it's like the guy who's

16:47

protecting power is so drenched himself in power that he doesn't have to be sort of a smart

16:53

operator in order to get things done because he just has his hands on all the levers.

16:58

And so he doesn't put like the way in which he and Nora talk to each other in the elevator

17:04

when he sort of lets her know what he has on her and how he can discredit her.

17:10

I thought that was just really satisfying to have worthy adversary for someone like Nora

17:16

who is a very smart person who is tangled up in her, you know, gets in her own way as

17:22

do most of these characters.

17:23

Well, especially someone who is smart because he is evolved.

17:27

Like not evolved in a sense that he has or says all the right things or does all the

17:30

right things, but he's a political animal adapted.

17:33

Yes.

17:34

I guess survival of the fittest kind of way, except in this case, it's like he grew more

17:37

scales and is more slimy and like knows how to frame things in just the appropriate

17:43

way to keep his job and survive the like, it sounds like pretty grim and brutal upbringing

17:49

of his own time in the office and then what he did to people like Nora in the first

17:52

place and how brutal he was as a boss.

17:54

And now he's the mental health guy.

17:56

You know, no, no, he's just looking up everyone's best interests.

17:58

Oh my God, disgusting.

17:59

Um, prestige TV is Spotify.com if you want to email us about that or anything else.

18:03

About your bosses who resemble Ed George.

18:05

Correct.

18:06

And the scales that they have grown over the years.

18:08

Um, episode five, pick a sticker written by Dan LeFronk and directed by Destiny, like

18:14

Araga.

18:15

Um, I thought this was a fantastic episode.

18:18

Yes.

18:19

Um, you know, the show.

18:21

I'm not really feeling like distinct individual flavors between the episodes, you know,

18:26

like I can really see a director's flourish in this one or that kind of thing.

18:29

It doesn't really feel like that kind of show.

18:32

It feels just more like a consistent steady hand on the on the tiller of the storytelling.

18:38

I think some of that too is we're, we're kind of equally weighted between these two leads

18:42

stories for the most part and the trajectories they're on.

18:45

It's like you already have these two tracks.

18:46

You don't need to get too cute in the way you kind of show them visually week to week

18:51

to make it feel like widow's Bay or whatever.

18:53

Right.

18:54

I think the best I could say for it is sort of instead of the one where X does what, you

18:59

know, it's sort of like the Campbell Scott episode, you know what I mean?

19:04

The Rob Delaney.

19:05

The one where Rob Delaney does.

19:06

The one where Campbell Scott does, you know, there is like a creep of the week.

19:09

Yeah.

19:10

I'm here that is great work for character actors.

19:12

If you were willing to subject yourself to that, if you're willing to be like the pedophile

19:15

or pedophile adjacent person, you know, there's good work to be done.

19:19

All these guys lined up for the show and I applaud them.

19:21

And they've been great.

19:22

They happen really good.

19:23

So we open with Catherine and Alden, you know, in bed together.

19:31

And this follow up of the end of last week's episode when she was talking about how she

19:35

can feel her fingertips, you know, this sort of trauma response that she had been navigating

19:41

where she's like, I can't feel anything.

19:44

Isn't that interesting?

19:46

And then, you know, Alden professors is loved to her.

19:51

And my interpretation, you know, I'll see now we're discussing this, but my interpretation

19:54

was like, that was a healing moment for there was something like traumatized inside of

19:59

her that was somewhat healed so that she could sort of feel the end of her fingertips

20:04

again.

20:05

And then by the end of this episode, when she sees what's on that how has what how has

20:11

on the computer, she's back into her sort of, you know, when she's trying to mess with

20:15

a sticker or she's back into the space where she can feel things.

20:19

Yeah.

20:20

Uh, Catherine Grace, a murderer, but also I feel emotionally devastated for her that

20:27

she is like one step forward in healing and then immediately sort of two steps back into

20:33

trauma space.

20:34

That's what I kind of found it alarming earlier when you were saying you were hearing

20:37

from people who felt like they couldn't emotionally connect with these two characters.

20:40

Like I'm I'm locked in lockstep with both of them despite the fact that you may not

20:45

be able to get into their exact headspace, but how could you not at least try to wrap

20:49

your mind around what they've been through and what that would do to a person?

20:52

Absolutely.

20:53

And I love your read on it.

20:54

And specifically that sort of like regression back into losing feeling in her fingers again.

20:59

Like I think a lot of it comes from the idea that there is a kind of satisfaction that

21:05

can come from this sort of vengeance.

21:07

And I may be a kind of closure in a way if you can kill everyone who's in the photo

21:10

or on the list or whatever, you know, whatever your victim set ends up being if you're

21:14

someone like Catherine, but like that kind of resolution doesn't heal you.

21:18

Like you have to do something else to do that.

21:21

And it probably starts with having real healthy human connections.

21:24

Like I mean, Alden is that seemingly the healthiest human connection she has with anyone

21:29

else on this show, even then it's still quite artificial and still quite fake.

21:32

And I think one of the miracles of what little a little pedagogy is doing is like the flicker

21:39

of like, is that a real thing that she's hiding within this larger speech or larger deception?

21:44

Like there are these moments that are like blink and you'll miss them.

21:47

Where you kind of buy what she's selling.

21:50

And I have no idea what's real and what's not, but that's kind of the magic of this performance.

21:54

I do think when she tells how I just don't want him to be alone, right, that just felt

22:00

so honest, like incredibly true.

22:04

And I don't know.

22:05

You're just like, okay, no, these two crazy kids cannot make it work.

22:09

But is there a way in which this connection could be something healthy?

22:14

I mean, something Yasi and I were talking about is sort of like, where do you want this

22:18

character, Catherine Grace to end at the end of the season?

22:21

Should she die and pursue to her actual goal?

22:27

Should she wind up in prison?

22:28

Should she get to go to Zewat now and like get off, got free?

22:33

Like what's the ending for her?

22:35

And I can't tell what exactly yet what show we're watching here.

22:38

And I like that.

22:39

It's sort of similar to what you're talking about in terms of like, is old and going to

22:42

be okay?

22:43

Yes.

22:44

Is this girl mirror going to be okay?

22:46

Like is Catherine Grace going to be okay?

22:48

Not in an okay that I think she's done nothing wrong and doesn't deserve any consequences

22:53

for her actions.

22:54

But like, I don't know.

22:56

I get this way.

22:58

Even with something like, did you ever see Red Dragon or read Red Dragon?

23:02

Yeah.

23:03

Right.

23:04

Yeah.

23:05

So like in Red Dragon, her Refin's plays a formal serial killer.

23:08

But there's this just like moment of true connection between him and Emily Watson's

23:13

character.

23:14

And it's like for a moment, you're just sort of like, what could have been if they had,

23:18

if he had found this kind of empathy or connection with someone before he did all this stuff that

23:25

is sort of like, uncombat from a bowl.

23:27

You know what I mean?

23:28

And so that's sort of my feeling when I see these two in bed and she's just sort of like

23:33

gently running her fingertips on his arm and it's just sort of this like beautiful

23:37

connective moment that I don't know if I want to say she doesn't, does or doesn't

23:44

deserve it.

23:45

But I just found myself like drawn into it.

23:47

Yes.

23:48

Well, especially, I mean, this is why no show that I have seen basically has ever been

23:52

able to resist the, you're not so different.

23:54

You and I kind of structures like you want those moments of humanity, even in the murderers,

23:59

even in the people doing crazy crimes or horrible things to people.

24:02

Like you want to feel that pull.

24:04

And it's so tempting to have.

24:07

And it's so structurally satisfying.

24:08

And it's like it's what draws you into those stories in a way that can sustain having

24:13

us spend half a season with a character like that where they're not just murder, they're

24:16

not just murdering people.

24:18

But you also hear in this episode and over the last couple like the parallels in Alice's

24:22

life, right?

24:23

Like there are parallel lines to a certain point between Alice and Catherine and Isabelle

24:29

basically.

24:30

And they go off in opposite directions, but like Alice was a teenage girl who was pregnant

24:34

at one time too and her life could have unraveled in a totally different direction.

24:38

And she ended up here.

24:39

I'm going to be honest here.

24:40

It doesn't seem great either in very different ways.

24:42

Like she's got a lot going on and a lot she's trying to work through, but needless to

24:46

say, she's lived an entirely different life than these other two girls have.

24:49

Would you say it's almost like a fractured broken mirror left on the wall of a

24:55

universe?

24:56

A first apartment.

24:57

But a mirror you fractured yourself because you were seeking out something kind of resembling

25:02

the very violence that puts you into this mental space to begin with.

25:05

It's not always a subtle show, but I really like it.

25:07

It's not.

25:08

But here's the thing, like it's not subtle.

25:10

Yeah.

25:11

But one thing I always appreciate with a show like this is like this show to me is all

25:14

about survival mechanisms, right?

25:16

It's like whether you have done horrible things, right?

25:19

Or have had horrible things done to you.

25:21

How do you pick up and move on?

25:22

Like how do you take the next step back into the real world?

25:25

And every character is dealing with some version of that.

25:28

And so yeah, it's not like everyone is on these like incredibly distinct journeys.

25:32

Like they're all interwoven.

25:33

They're all overlapping.

25:34

They're messy and really good and I think interesting ways.

25:38

Yeah.

25:39

But it's at least kind of cohesive in the story that it's trying to tell.

25:42

And like to me, the very real human responses to a lot of this stuff.

25:45

There's also of course this interesting skin of a Greek tragedy that the show is painted

25:54

on top of all this.

25:55

And in that like, you know, we start with the story of Medusa.

25:58

Sure.

25:59

And episode one, we get the sort of various strains of fury inside of Greek storytelling,

26:06

Greek thinking.

26:07

And then I've been thinking a lot about, you know, the room that Nora goes into to watch

26:15

these horrible videos.

26:18

And what she tells Alice is like, that's your award, right?

26:23

Yeah.

26:24

You get access to that.

26:27

You get to go into hell and hang out in hell and see how you do if that's a place you

26:32

spend time with.

26:33

Like see how you cope.

26:35

And if you don't wind up drinking a straight rye whiskey out of your family or something

26:40

like that at the end of the day.

26:41

So like, yeah.

26:43

And this idea of Nora as this sort of, I love this Nora character.

26:47

That's an amazing character.

26:48

That's a really good character, incredible performance.

26:50

But like, this idea of like the avenging angel, but the cost of just sort of even spending

26:57

any time being an avenging angel inside of this.

27:00

And then also the compromise is, like the compromise is she made to even stay here to make

27:04

any kind of difference.

27:07

Is she had to at one point along the way and we still don't know all the details of it,

27:10

but she had to compromise on this Jane Doe case.

27:14

Yeah.

27:15

In order to just even stay, it seems like in order to even just stay inside of the department,

27:19

you know?

27:20

So I think, yeah, the marriage just keeps one term.

27:24

They really do.

27:25

I mean, so many characters are making that sort of compromise.

27:27

Yueniyasi touched on that last week too with the teenage girl who was also like complicit

27:31

in the trafficking of other girls.

27:33

It's like everyone is getting pulled into these systems and making compromises to protect

27:37

themselves.

27:38

Yeah.

27:39

One thing I loved about this episode is it felt like Alice was almost making the inverted

27:42

choice where her, I mean, the bargain she has struck or the approach she has chosen to

27:48

take is like, can you swap?

27:50

Follow your pain and your pride to basically like engage in this sexual or faux sexual situation

27:59

with this guy who abused you for the sake of like getting your professional career back

28:04

under your feet again.

28:05

Like can you get this case back and maybe some kind of power back if you're willing to

28:10

swallow all this other stuff?

28:11

Right.

28:12

When Nore is like, this is the thing in your way.

28:13

You can clear this out of the way.

28:15

Then you can get back to doing what you want to do.

28:16

And she does it in like the most fucked up way possible.

28:19

And she's like, I'm like, really good.

28:22

When she pulls that bag out, I guess we're not, let's not worry about going exactly in

28:26

chronological order.

28:27

When she pulls the bag out, Fiona Apple kicks in.

28:29

Yeah.

28:30

That's how you know.

28:31

That's how you know.

28:33

And to watch her open the bag and for those of us watching at home to begin to process

28:39

what it is she's looking at.

28:41

And she's looking at artifacts of her old life and you're wondering, why did she keep,

28:47

you know, there's a party that's sort of like, why did she keep this, why did she keep

28:50

this clothing that you bought for her?

28:54

These photographs of them as teenagers and all the sorts of like that.

28:58

And for that to happen and just the way that the photographs are stacked for you to see

29:06

them so young, for you to see them actually quite recently.

29:10

Like this photo was clearly taken on the set of this show.

29:13

Like they are, look the same age they are.

29:15

They have the same hair that they have.

29:16

Like this is a recent in their, in these characters lives photograph.

29:21

But there's more flash so you know it's point and click early 2000's photography.

29:26

But you can see the, the, the photos of her bruised and battered face sort of like in the

29:32

stack, the way that the photos are being held.

29:34

It's not like a jump scare that you like come across it.

29:36

It's there and just slowly being uncovered.

29:40

So the music doesn't change.

29:42

It's still Fiona like, you know, but her result, like she gets sort of lost in this sort

29:49

of my interpretation of the way that Emmy Rossum was playing this was like, she gets lost

29:54

in this sort of slight soft nostalgia for who she was in the more innocent times of that

30:01

relationship and the safety that she thought that she found there.

30:06

And then seeing those photos of her own face puts this deal back in her spine in terms

30:12

of like what she has to now do.

30:14

To entrap Marshall.

30:16

If that's how you choose to find it.

30:19

And I think what she does only really works because of that soft nostalgia part.

30:24

Like because there is still a part of her that is holding on to like you said, the version

30:29

of her that used to exist, the version of relationships used to have like who she thought

30:32

Marshall was before he revealed to he was all of those things.

30:35

Like there is a connection between them.

30:38

And there is something that she is tapping into that is still there.

30:42

It's just like covered up with so much scar tissue because of everything else.

30:45

And it's like she needs all of that to be Catherine level manipulative in this setting.

30:52

Right.

30:53

It's like using sex as a weapon to get what you want.

30:55

Like we've seen Catherine do it many times throughout the course of the season already

30:58

to say nothing of what she's had to do before to survive.

31:01

It's like you kind of have to have that other part to tap into it for exactly this sort

31:06

of thing.

31:07

What I love about what both Catherine does and what Alice does here is that they are relying

31:14

upon the weaknesses inside of these men in order to accomplish the gambit here.

31:20

So like for example, with Rob Delaney's character, a perfect asshole.

31:26

But for her to if he had just actually kicked her out when he first sort of thinks about

31:33

like, okay, you got to go.

31:35

Nice morning, you got to go.

31:37

I don't know that he would have necessarily survived, but like he would have set himself

31:42

up.

31:43

But she's like, no, no, I'll stay here.

31:44

I'll do whatever you know, she sort of like lays out this temptation in front of him

31:48

that he can't resist to this sort of like I own you my power over you all the sort

31:53

of stuff like that.

31:54

Just sort of like walks himself into this trap.

31:57

And similarly even tries to think that he doesn't want it.

32:00

And then he's like staring at the security camera work, you know.

32:05

You know, and then the guy winds up being Campbell Scott's like son the way.

32:10

I mean, that whole sequence where she's just sort of like parked herself up at the table

32:14

and taking fake zoom calls is just like incredible.

32:17

But she's just sort of like relying on, you know, again, all of the characters inside

32:22

of the show are quite smart.

32:24

And so the cunning that she uses and the way in which she knows how to manipulate people

32:29

and find out where their weaknesses are and where they're sort of like were too liberal

32:35

to throw this woman out of our house sort of.

32:38

She folded that boy up into some tinfish.

32:41

She just sealed him right up.

32:42

It was nothing.

32:43

Tinfish boy.

32:44

What did you think about tinfish coming back in another show so soon?

32:48

Fitting and alarming.

32:49

Yeah.

32:50

But it's kind of in this like guys, you know, but you I mean look, yuppie liberals of a

32:53

certain kind do love tinfish.

32:55

It happened in its moment in the last couple of years.

32:57

But yeah, what do you think about the trap that Alice Lee's for Marshall here?

33:03

The seduction is not just her and sort of like Emmy Rossum said in an interview with

33:07

Golderby that it was like her idea to put like his hands on his throat and stuff like

33:12

that.

33:14

And then and then how the alcohol is sort of like woven into that, this sort of like

33:19

breaking of his sobriety resolve at the same time.

33:23

I mean, this is excruciating to watch and so well done for exactly those reasons.

33:28

I think there's a couple of different elements.

33:31

One, just the idea of Alice as basically a compulsive liar is something we've established

33:37

all throughout the season.

33:38

You give this girl any chance to tell a version of her backstory that is not real and she

33:42

will do it for the sake of getting like one inch closer to the things that she wants.

33:46

But then there's also this part of it where I mean, frankly, just the idea that a TV

33:51

show in 2026 would have a victim of sexual, like of domestic violence to do so her abuser

33:59

using her sexuality that it's willing to do that.

34:02

Like the balls on this show, frankly, the three dimensionality of these characters.

34:07

Like, I just think a lot of shows fall into what can be a very understandable trap when

34:13

they delve into things like domestic violence of they try to get so seriously.

34:18

And it's very well meaning I think in a lot of cases where it's like, this is what

34:21

this character becomes.

34:22

It's very precious.

34:23

It's very precious.

34:24

They are confined to the space.

34:27

Everything they do in their life is through the lens of this thing.

34:30

And part of what I appreciate about this sequence and the fact that she would even do this

34:32

in the first place is that being assaulted doesn't change you from being a human who wants

34:39

other things.

34:40

Right.

34:41

There's a lot of stuff going on in Alice's head.

34:42

I wouldn't even dare to know what's going on up there.

34:45

But she wants to know who this murderer is.

34:48

She wants to get back on this case.

34:49

She wants resolution.

34:50

She wants to figure out what happened to these other girls and women.

34:53

She wants to know who, which assholes and power are implicated in this.

34:56

She wants to go back to work.

34:57

And this is the thing standing in her way and her way of dealing with it is not super healthy.

35:02

But it is a thing that she wants.

35:03

I like that even the damaged part of her is willing to subject herself to something

35:10

like this for the sake of a weird bizarre outcome.

35:13

They're like, I would never have expected and just makes for good TV.

35:15

People similarly with Catherine Grace, the fact that she's like in order to, I mean,

35:20

she could just meet these guys and shoot them in the street.

35:22

She could.

35:23

That's not what she's looking to do.

35:24

She's looking to torment them.

35:26

And part of the torment is, I mean, she has sex with them.

35:30

And she makes them believe that she wants to and that she cares about them and all these

35:36

other things in order to make the vengeance feel like tastes that much more delicious

35:41

for her.

35:42

In this Gold Derby interview, this is what Amy Rossum said about sort of,

35:45

a lot of what you're saying about the compulsive liar aspect of Alice and then also the

35:53

kernels of truth that are exist inside its interaction she has with Marshall, right?

35:58

So she says, I think that Alice is a shapeshifter.

36:01

It's almost like she's acting a lot of the time, but we get to see her vulnerability and

36:04

her truth when we're alone with her.

36:06

So that she was saying that to underline the section of the episode where we watch her

36:11

get ready.

36:12

And that's like the most truthful Alice because known else is observing her.

36:17

It's just us at her and the broken mirror.

36:19

She goes on to say, but a lot like what I think acting is, she's often using the truth

36:22

to make a trick work or commitment to a truth to make a trick work.

36:26

And so we see her shapeshift into a softer, younger version here.

36:29

Her clothes are different.

36:30

Her approach is different.

36:31

I want her voice timber to be different and settler and softer.

36:35

There are some things that she's saying that are true.

36:37

She's a little bit drunk.

36:38

She did have a terrible day at work.

36:39

She's wearing these old clothes.

36:41

She's really bad at decorating the house, but she's saying them in a way that lures

36:44

him in and won't make him suspect that her ultimate goal is to waterboard him with whiskey,

36:48

to tempt him to lure him in and to compromise his sobriety.

36:51

I have two logistical questions about this episode.

36:55

One is do the cops show up that quickly even if it's Nozy neighbor Margaret who's calling

37:02

in the I saw drunk guy outside.

37:05

You already know that they don't.

37:06

Also Margaret has called the police many times.

37:08

So many times.

37:09

The police station is like, okay, this woman again, like, take your time.

37:12

Okay.

37:13

Number two, have you ever in your life seen a wanted poster of someone?

37:18

No, and multiple people are seeing it and calling it in and registered.

37:22

Yeah, here's the thing.

37:23

I was like, where would I even find one?

37:26

My issue is in part the wanted poster.

37:28

Yeah.

37:29

And in part Alice's recognition at the end of this episode in a distorted reflection that

37:35

the woman in front of her is in fact the girl she has seen at age 14 in a photo.

37:42

I simply could not do it, but I'm not an FBI agent.

37:46

I'm not a detective of her caliber.

37:48

Yeah, I'm paying a lot of attention to things, Rob.

37:50

That's deeply interesting.

37:52

Yeah, the water poster really got me for both Alden.

37:57

Yeah.

37:58

When Alden has it, but then also the other care workers, I saw it, I called it in.

38:02

And I was just like, where does one find like, is it like the next door app?

38:09

Is that what we're looking on?

38:10

There's also like crime.

38:11

Like when I lived in Oakland, I lived with a guy who would check the crime reporting app

38:16

like all the time.

38:17

And I was like, how is this helping you enjoy your life here in Oakland, California?

38:23

It's not keeping you safer.

38:25

It's not doing anything.

38:27

But perhaps that is like a place where I wanted to make them up.

38:30

But other than that, I don't.

38:32

Facebook, I don't know where one finds a wanted poster.

38:34

On a Bolton board at the post office?

38:36

Right.

38:37

I don't know what the local coffee shop.

38:38

A bodega, perhaps?

38:40

I don't know.

38:41

That was, those were just some logistical questions I had about communication of.

38:45

You know what, plot needs must.

38:47

People needed to know that she was a wanted fugitive.

38:49

And so, you know, the word is getting out.

38:51

Hey, I just then moved you for rent.

38:53

Nice.

38:54

Now I can instantly spend it whether I'm checking out online with them or using the

38:57

Vemmo Devicle.

38:58

Same more.

38:59

More exactly.

39:01

Because the more you do with Vemmo, the more you get.

39:03

Like earning up to 5% cash back with Vemmo Stas on a bundle of brains.

39:07

So, order more pizza.

39:09

The math demands it.

39:10

Get the Vemmo Devicle.

39:12

Vemmo Stas bundle terms and exclusions apply.

39:14

See terms of Vemmo.me slash dash term.

39:16

Vemmo check out not available with all merchants.

39:18

Vemmo MasterCard is issued by the bank or bank NA.

39:21

Should we talk about Campbell Scott?

39:23

How?

39:23

I would love to.

39:24

Roger Dodger himself.

39:25

OK.

39:27

So, the idea of him being adjacent to a kind of pickup artistry, if not womanizing,

39:34

if not who knows what's worse than that and Roger Dodger's life.

39:37

I really missed you Rob because I was just about to ask you what role you most associate

39:42

with Campbell Scott.

39:43

Your answer is Roger Dodger.

39:45

It is.

39:46

A movie that most people as easily as this podcast have not seen, but it is Jesse Eisenberg

39:51

and Campbell Scott, early Jesse Eisenberg.

39:53

And it is about a young man who learns from his uncle how to pick up women.

39:59

That's not to.

40:01

They learn from each other along the way.

40:02

Honestly, I think it would hold up.

40:04

I think it's very knowing about how slimy it is.

40:07

Not your touch.

40:08

It's such a while full.

40:10

Well, what's yours?

40:11

What's your touch point?

40:12

Singles, where are you?

40:14

Singles is a good one.

40:15

The Spanish prisoner is one I really love.

40:18

I think seeing like Hope Davis and Campbell Scott who were just sort of like twin icons

40:22

of a certain era of late 90s indie film is really fun.

40:28

Low here we are in the mucket in the trenches from our sort of whimsy era of independent

40:34

cinema.

40:35

But Roger Dodger is a great answer and I'm proud of you for it.

40:38

Thank you very much.

40:39

But Campbell Scott, I'm used to liking Campbell Scott.

40:46

And so obviously the show is leveraging that with a number of actors that they've chosen

40:50

to use here.

40:51

And for him to plead his case as someone who's on her side, and I've got my laptop here,

40:58

and I've got information.

41:00

And we can take him down together.

41:02

And I've been, he's a piece of shit and I've been wanting to take him down.

41:07

And not only that, but also when she's talking about getting married and she gets the wedding

41:12

dress out and he's sort of like, yes, ending her and supporting her.

41:16

As he sums.

41:17

And she turns her back and he's like, I'm going to fucking die here.

41:22

I thought all of that was really good.

41:24

It's an amazing scene.

41:26

I also think I love this layer of Catherine too, where I mean, again, the psychoanalysis,

41:31

I think is a dangerous slippery slope to get into with her, where I'm like why she does

41:35

the things that she does.

41:37

But it does seem like she wants in the arrested development way that you and Yossi were talking

41:42

about with her, like the approval or the support of these men at times.

41:47

Like she does kind of want him to say that she looks beautiful in the wedding dress.

41:51

And she, and she does want like, I love that her like signature move is like pillow talk.

41:56

Like she drugs these guys into oblivion and then lays one inch from their face.

42:00

And it has like this real unguarded moment of intimacy with them in which they cannot

42:06

move.

42:07

They are subject to whatever she wants to say.

42:08

And it's like, there is a, it like, look, it's not tenderness.

42:11

I don't know what it is.

42:12

But like there is something that she is clearly looking for from these men beyond just killing

42:18

them, although like the killing them seems pretty satisfying too.

42:21

Well, I do think it's interesting that like we have not been taken inside the actions

42:27

of this horrible photograph that we've seen.

42:31

And obviously there are like horrible abuses there.

42:34

But I guess based off of my unfortunate time with Jeffrey Epstein, documentaries that

42:40

I watched when we were covering industry, there is this story that a lot of these abusers

42:47

tell themselves that they are helping these young women.

42:52

We are giving them things they didn't have access to.

42:55

Yeah, like money, opportunity, this is, this is, this was the Glenn Maxwell, Jeffrey

43:00

Epstein log line was like, we are giving them opportunity.

43:03

You're giving them clothing.

43:04

They couldn't have job opportunities.

43:06

They couldn't have, you know, we are helping them.

43:09

Actually, they're horribly abusing them.

43:11

But just sort of like the way in which it's wrapped up in this pretensive care.

43:16

And so I think the way in which she is dishing that pretensive care back to them while

43:21

destroying them at the same time, I think is really interesting.

43:24

I guess my question for you is like, do you think that is a jab or is that an honest return

43:30

of some of that care?

43:31

Like, you know, like all of her Charles giving her the glass of water, and she brings

43:34

him the glass of water, is that a poke at him for knowing, like he should have known

43:39

how horrible a guy he was?

43:41

Or is it like in this weird fucked up way I was in a hell hole and you did give me a glass

43:46

of water?

43:47

It's kind of more interesting if it's the latter.

43:49

Yeah.

43:50

I think if, if, if her emotions around it are more complex than that.

43:54

Yes.

43:55

And, and what is even more complex about someone like Hal is for him to tell the story

44:01

to himself that he was not one of the abusers.

44:04

Yeah.

44:05

Um, that he wasn't there until later, that he was protecting him.

44:09

There's like, there's a clue dropped here that we don't really know what he's talking

44:13

about.

44:14

He says I was protecting her, protecting her from him.

44:17

Right.

44:18

Pronouns.

44:19

We don't know what we're talking about.

44:21

But presumably that is probably the biggest smoking gun pointing to the Isabel's daughter

44:27

versus sister theory, right?

44:28

Right.

44:29

Of like the her and question would be Isabel's daughter with Jay Eston maybe, and protecting

44:35

her from him.

44:36

Oh, yeah.

44:37

Right.

44:38

I think that would be kind of where my mind would go.

44:39

But there's a lot of tangles going on here.

44:42

That's, that's a great interpretation, I think.

44:44

But, but this added wrinkle also of Catherine basically admitting that she doesn't remember

44:50

what I, you know, and so she's on this vengeance tree, but she's also actually trying to find

44:56

out because she's like, I don't, I don't know who else is on my list.

45:00

Yeah.

45:01

Because I don't, I know who was in this photo.

45:02

Yep.

45:03

I can find them.

45:04

Yeah.

45:05

But I don't know who else is on the list because I don't know what actually happened.

45:09

And so, you know, something I was saying to Yasi, which I guess now is not true, but I

45:13

was just sort of like, I like that the point of this show is not what happened because

45:18

we kind of know what happened.

45:19

But now I guess we kind of don't know exactly what happened.

45:22

I guess my question is what the alarm bells it, it kicks off for me is if Catherine in

45:30

her various trauma responses can't remember what happened.

45:34

Yeah.

45:35

Is she somehow in whatever degree complicit in what happened?

45:40

Do you know what I mean?

45:41

Yeah.

45:42

Like has she blocked it because something happened that she feels responsible for one way or another?

45:47

Or is the reason Isabel got tangled up in any of this to begin with somehow because

45:52

of her?

45:53

Like is there a chain of events by which she feels rightly or wrongly responsible for

45:57

what happened?

45:58

I think feels very possible.

45:59

I love the fuzziness of this and her trying to put the pieces together as much as anybody.

46:03

And yeah, it could be a pure trauma response like dissociative, like just like blocking out

46:08

what happened that night because it was so awful and such a terrible moment.

46:12

It could be we're told repeatedly these girls are just like pumped full of drugs in these

46:15

moments.

46:16

And so maybe she's just literally out of her senses.

46:19

And this was one of those moments where I wasn't sure how much to trust the earnestness

46:23

of what she was saying.

46:24

But when she was saying like her theory is like she was literally strangled so much that

46:28

her memory is bad now.

46:30

Right.

46:31

And so it's like there's so many ways in which this person has just been put through

46:34

the ringer of life by these men that it could be any of them or all of them all at once.

46:39

And also the when she tells the Hello Kitty story and she's like, I did this and she's

46:43

like actually or was that Isabel the way in which she was sort of like blurred their experiences

46:48

together.

46:49

And you know, the sort of idea of like I was in love with her.

46:53

She let me look at her eye fucking sort of thing.

46:56

So this idea of like and the, you know, the woman who gave this backstory information

47:03

about them in the previous episode, how she was just sort of like there was something.

47:07

Some weird going on there.

47:08

Something weird before we got here.

47:10

There was something weird going on.

47:12

So like this idea of like coveting someone, blurring your personality or your experiences

47:19

with them and all of that, all of that was already kind of in the mix before we got to

47:25

this degree of damage for someone like Catherine Grace.

47:28

Especially with how little we know of Isabel otherwise.

47:30

Like most of what we know is through the lens of either police reports that, I mean,

47:36

let me stop you from the freeze framing.

47:38

Don't freeze frame and read the police reports.

47:39

Like they are among the most heinous things you will read in terms of like the injuries

47:43

that Isabel suffered before dying.

47:44

And I believe in episode four, there was an allusion to the fact that like her face was

47:48

unrecognizable or lots of, lots of horrible stuff happening.

47:52

But most of what we hear from about Isabel is from a police report or Catherine's memory

47:58

or like this sister slash daughter's memory or this like home, like group home worker.

48:04

All kind of second and third hand and fuzzy and 15 years ago.

48:08

It's like we really don't know a lot about her story yet.

48:10

And so we're just starting to get these bits and pieces to connect the dots of who Isabel

48:14

was in the first place.

48:15

Yeah, it's a great point.

48:18

Anything else you want to talk about that we have not gotten to?

48:22

On the Hello Kitty front, this is a sharp turn.

48:25

I apologize to you and to everyone else.

48:27

How aware are you of the fact that Hello Kitty is not a cat?

48:31

For some reason, very.

48:32

Oh, see, she's a girl.

48:33

Yes.

48:34

For those not in the know.

48:36

Hello Kitty is a human girl.

48:39

I don't know if she's wearing a cat mask.

48:41

I don't know if she did like a nip tuck style like make me look like a cat.

48:45

Hunger game sort of a lot of plastic surgery happening.

48:48

I don't know what happened, but she has, I believe herself, an actual cat, which feels

48:53

fucked up.

48:54

Look, it's not my area.

48:55

I'm more of a more of a like a like botz maroo guy personally for kind of diving.

49:00

But I just the second this came up, it was all I could think about was like, man, I forgot

49:04

that Hello Kitty is not a cat.

49:05

And it's fucked up that nobody's talking about, including Adrian Marado, who loves Hello

49:10

Kitty.

49:11

Do you think he knows that Hello Kitty is not a cat, but actually, if you're on.

49:14

I think if he did, it would have broken him.

49:18

While we're here in left turn, Lynn, let's do it.

49:21

I want to go back to the scene, but I didn't really earlier because it didn't feel appropriate.

49:24

Okay.

49:25

But you've set the tone.

49:26

Thank you.

49:27

Arlister Mo wrote it to say, this email is about the revelation that one can make tuna

49:32

salad with more ingredients than just tuna and mayo.

49:35

I've heard a salary being added, of course, but Rob's total dismay near horror over

49:39

hearing the simplicity of Joe's recipe for tuna salad.

49:42

As me curious, this is left or from Cape Fear.

49:44

I honestly did not know there was another way to make it.

49:47

What does Rob add to it?

49:49

Relish, mustard, spices.

49:50

I mean, I feel like you simply don't really eat tuna salad.

49:53

The answer is don't do it.

49:55

Yeah.

49:56

Because you're of your aunt, I want better of all of you.

49:59

All of you out there and certainly a few, Joe, like I just want better for you than

50:02

tuna salad.

50:03

Tuna salad is great.

50:04

And here's the thing, if you're going to eat tuna salad and it's just tuna and mayo

50:07

for God's sake, season your food, like you've got to put something in there.

50:11

I'm personally like for a cockay in there.

50:12

That's you were getting somewhere?

50:14

Yeah.

50:15

But also don't do it.

50:16

Like just there are other foods.

50:17

Tuna salad is delicious.

50:18

Oh, absolutely not.

50:19

No fish salad, no white fish salad, no fish salad at all.

50:22

What about like a nice wild salad, like tuna on a salad?

50:26

I still wouldn't.

50:27

You're kind of anti tuna, especially anything that's coming out of a can or a pouch or

50:33

involves cheese?

50:34

No.

50:35

That's the so elitist of you.

50:36

Some of us survived in college off of 75% can of tuna.

50:40

Eat a 99 cent pot pie.

50:42

You know, eat a cup of noodles.

50:43

Like there are alternatives that I'm not, look, I'm not saying they're healthy, but they

50:47

taste better than that.

50:48

Anything else?

50:49

So we haven't gotten too to the salad or otherwise.

50:52

I like you.

50:53

And I think like most people after episode four, very dismayed at the trajectory of Nora's

50:57

character, like her kind of recoiling, trying to cover her own ass, like buying into the

51:04

security of her career over advancing the case in episode four, very tough stuff.

51:08

But I think Alice reals her back in a little bit and kind of gets her more invested in

51:13

proceeding with the case.

51:14

Yeah.

51:15

I think she does it in a very clever way too that speaks to Alice's like situational awareness

51:20

and understanding of people of like her appeal to Nora is not do the right thing or

51:25

like open this case back up for some moral reason.

51:27

It's like dangling the puzzle piece of the not hospital hospital bracelet of like this

51:32

thing that she knows Nora was interested in in the case she did care about.

51:36

You almost got there.

51:37

Like you almost got it.

51:38

And I think we can, I think we can crack it together.

51:41

That being what brings Nora back in, I found to be like again, just like a great turn

51:45

for a great character in the show.

51:46

I agree.

51:48

Where are you on my guy Frank Choi?

51:50

Are you a Choi boy?

51:52

First of all, no one is a Choi boy.

51:55

The miracle of Frank Choi is like, he's such a wannabe guys guy and also the most like

52:00

unapologetic brown nose I've ever seen to a degree that literally everyone hates him.

52:05

It's remarkable.

52:07

Honestly incredible work by him to alienate literally everyone in your workplace.

52:10

Should we consider Choi boys a G.

52:13

I'm like, only if you are the aforementioned Choi boy.

52:18

I'm my bitch.

52:19

It simply wouldn't be me, but I love what Rob being is doing.

52:23

I think he's so funny.

52:24

It's so funny.

52:25

It's such a great presence to have in the office.

52:27

We're again, like everything else is ultra serious all the time.

52:30

And here's just this fucking idea.

52:32

Everyone hates.

52:33

Yeah.

52:34

When I said everyone is smart, I forgot Frank Choi not smart.

52:37

Everyone else pretty smart.

52:38

But I think an important presence on a show like this where if you are having people

52:42

who it's like this guy beat up Alice, these super rich men are involved in trafficking

52:49

young girls.

52:50

Like people are truly awful.

52:51

Yes.

52:52

And you need someone who's many, many, many, many rungs down who's just like this guy sucks.

52:56

Yeah.

52:57

You know, like this guy sucks in a real basic way.

52:59

He doesn't make my skin crawl.

53:00

He just sucks all the time.

53:02

And by comparison, I love watching it.

53:04

Yeah.

53:05

I'm also I'm a Yara fan.

53:09

I don't know.

53:10

Yara is just is here to be like pregnant kind of over right.

53:14

But all about mental health and is quite helpful inside of the department.

53:17

I mean, she seems like a joy to have in class.

53:19

Yeah.

53:20

Joy to have in the workplace.

53:21

Just a bright light for everyone who knows her.

53:23

All right.

53:24

Anything else?

53:25

The only other thing I wanted to circle back to is that moment where Danny asks Alice to

53:29

come with him to New Jersey of all places as one does.

53:34

But specifically, Alice is responsible.

53:36

Coming down on Cantuna and the Jersey Shore.

53:39

I don't think that's a controversial take.

53:40

I think there are some nice spots on the Jersey Shore.

53:43

Even that you're couching it within couch.

53:45

You're like, there is this little spot where the sun shines just right and that place

53:49

would be okay to stand for a moment is what you just said about the Jersey Shore.

53:53

It could be nice.

53:54

It could be nice.

53:55

The point here isn't necessarily that it's nice.

53:56

He even says it's going to be freezing.

53:58

It's probably going to be terrible.

53:59

But you know what it's mean.

54:00

Me and Montauk, you know, it's not here.

54:03

What did you make of Alice's response to this though where I like she seems.

54:06

It's touched in the moment.

54:08

In like her immediate response, like I think the gesture means something to her.

54:13

She also seems like deeply wounded, understandably.

54:17

And then goes home and screams and grounds herself and goes immediately back to work.

54:21

But like, what do you think she is going through in that moment?

54:23

She did the classic game.

54:24

Adam Sharp objects screaming to a piece of clothing move.

54:27

Love it.

54:28

Well, Claire Danes isn't around either.

54:29

So somebody's got to do it.

54:32

Maybe this is cheating to use somebody at the actor said, but Emmy Rossum said in that

54:38

Golderby interview that she said when she was talking about Marshall and what he's in

54:41

the way of, one of the things she said was in the way of her relationship with Danny.

54:47

Yeah.

54:48

Like just sort of like her unresolved issues around Marshall.

54:50

Or so it's not that.

54:52

And I think this is, I already thought this was like abundantly clear.

54:55

But like, it's not that she doesn't have feelings for Danny.

54:58

It's not like they are clearly.

55:00

She says that what he does is get scared women to fall in love with him.

55:03

Like it's a little autobiographical.

55:05

Clearly in love with each other.

55:07

Like clearly.

55:08

And I would love for those crazy kids to make it work, honestly.

55:13

But like the Marshall stuff is so unresolved and so in the way that she can't, it's sort

55:19

of like she can't feel her fingertips.

55:20

Like she can't connect with him because of this thing that's still lingering here.

55:25

And what I like about to go back to the sort of like why she lays his trap for Marshall

55:30

and you're talking, you were talking about the motivations here.

55:33

Her motivation is I want to get back on the case.

55:36

And it's not vengeance for what was done to her because she did not officially report

55:43

him when all of this happened in the first place, right?

55:46

She didn't set about to destroy his career or we can like dig into like why she didn't

55:51

report him.

55:52

But like, seems like she just tried to run away as far as she could.

55:55

She was just like, I don't want to be part of it.

55:57

And like he's the one who's like now showing up on, on her case, you know, so like,

56:02

um, so it's not that she was just sort of like, I'm going to get him for what he did

56:06

to me to your point.

56:07

It's like, I want to be able to do this work and also maybe go to the Jersey Shore with

56:14

Scoot McNair.

56:15

And I think she deserves it.

56:17

I think we all want to go to the Jersey Shore with Scoot McNair anyway.

56:20

This Marshall was Scoot McNair.

56:21

Yes, I do.

56:22

He plays so many dirt bags.

56:24

It's true.

56:25

It's nice for him to be like, it's still the dirt part of the dirt bag, but like he has

56:29

a heart of gold.

56:30

You can kind of smell him.

56:31

He's smell the cigarettes on him.

56:32

He can certainly can.

56:34

Um, maybe that's like sort of the nice like reverse of this other casting we've been

56:38

talking about in terms of like casting these sort of beloved figures as these complete

56:42

scumbags.

56:43

And then we're like, and we're going to take Scoot and make him just like the Swedish

56:47

nicest guy except I am very scared.

56:49

Not only.

56:50

And I said this to Yasi, I'm going to say it to you too.

56:52

Just in case the show is listening and they can change the ending if this is not the

56:55

ending already.

56:56

I'm worried about him dying.

56:57

Sure.

56:58

But more than that, I'm worried about him disappointing me.

57:01

Don't disappoint me, Danny Kelly.

57:03

Please don't do that.

57:04

Either Danny Kelly.

57:05

Either the ringer Danny Kelly.

57:07

The ringer Danny Kelly has never disappointed a soul and certainly never you are I know

57:11

that I'm an absolute saint.

57:13

I'll print some of my men.

57:14

Well, let me ask you this question.

57:15

While we're talking our beloved characters who are doing heinous things on this show,

57:19

yeah.

57:20

Campbell Scott clearly not a good guy.

57:21

The proximity to all of this human trafficking and having sex with underage girls horrible.

57:26

Don't do it.

57:28

Should not defend himself in any context.

57:30

His wife, Janelle Maloney, our beloved Dona Mosses here, at least my beloved Dona

57:35

Mosses here.

57:36

It's Janelle Maloney innocent.

57:37

How much does she know and when did she know it?

57:39

That's what I'm worried about.

57:40

If she just thinks she's married to a lawyer for rich guys, you're putting Dona on the

57:43

crosshairs.

57:44

I don't know.

57:45

You wouldn't stop a red lights to take your revenge on Dona.

57:50

I'm asking proximity to proximity to power.

57:53

How many rings out do you have to go out before people start getting in?

57:56

I mentioned this, but I do think this is why like Hope Davis and Janelle Maloney are like

58:00

really good castes in these very wasp-with-love white women who are daughter of or wife of these

58:10

creepy men.

58:13

These very specific types of women.

58:16

I don't know.

58:17

I'm curious.

58:18

Why is Hope Davis in the show?

58:19

She has more to do.

58:20

She has more to do.

58:21

She can't just be shown up for an occasional interrogation.

58:23

No.

58:24

That's not it.

58:25

No.

58:26

Anything else.

58:27

I think that's it.

58:28

I think we did it.

58:29

We really did.

58:30

At least for this week, there's so much more to happen on this show though.

58:32

It's true.

58:33

We've got five more episodes to go.

58:34

Actually, I lied to you.

58:35

There is one more thing.

58:36

Okay.

58:37

Look, my frees framing in the police files was not a good time for me.

58:41

My frees framing in Alden's room though.

58:43

Quite fruitful.

58:44

In particular, our guys got a blue velvet poster just hanging right there which might

58:48

be a cry for help to a certain audience, but I happened to respect.

58:52

Bad, listen, some bad religion.

58:54

Also, I think I like a predator poster.

58:57

I'm trying to remember what language it's in.

58:59

It's not in English.

59:00

Maybe Japanese predator poster.

59:01

I like to monitor setup.

59:02

Great.

59:03

Look, seems like he's doing some day trading.

59:05

He's doing quite well.

59:06

I think he's got a lot of money.

59:07

He's making it work.

59:08

Yeah.

59:09

I'm interested to see what happens.

59:11

Is he done with Catherine or is he going to be protective of her in some way?

59:17

I mean, he did literally just learn that her name was Catherine.

59:19

Is there real roller coaster of emotion for him between?

59:23

Will you be my girlfriend?

59:24

Oh, wait, your name is not Vanessa.

59:25

It's Catherine.

59:26

Oh, wait.

59:27

Will you marry me?

59:28

Oh, wait.

59:29

Is that your uncle?

59:30

Is that your uncle?

59:31

I lie.

59:32

I said, there's only three more episodes.

59:34

It's an eight episode season.

59:35

So only three more episodes to go.

59:37

Is Alden going to be okay?

59:39

Is Danny Kelly going to disappoint me?

59:42

Is Jayeest going to get got?

59:44

Yeah.

59:45

I'm mostly invested in him getting what's coming to him.

59:48

Well, he's going to get got one way or the other.

59:50

Well, I get true.

59:51

He does not have long for this world.

59:52

The question is can Catherine beat cancer to the punch?

59:55

I would like him to get got by something other than natural causes.

59:59

That would be my preference.

1:00:00

Feels more narrative satisfying, but maybe this is not a narrowly satisfying show in the

1:00:04

ways that we might want.

1:00:05

Anything else you want to talk about before we go?

1:00:07

I'm just so excited to be podcasting about the show.

1:00:09

I'm so glad we're doing furious.

1:00:10

Thank you for teeing it up.

1:00:11

Thank you to you and Yasi for starting us off with a bang.

1:00:14

I'm having a great time.

1:00:15

One last thing I'll say, this is one last quote from that gold derby interview, which

1:00:18

is just something I didn't really fully understand.

1:00:20

When she was talking about why I mean, we're also talking about why Alice can't shower.

1:00:27

It's not just the sort of like the trauma of the way in which Marshall used to like pull

1:00:31

her out of the shower in order to abuse her, but she says she can't get into the shower

1:00:35

and only because she can't shower, because she can't take the gun into the shower and

1:00:38

be vulnerable for a second.

1:00:40

Yes.

1:00:41

I have like the gun and like needing it on her person at all times.

1:00:46

Yeah.

1:00:47

I'm just going to end on that off note.

1:00:49

Thank you to Kai Grady.

1:00:51

Thank you to Jacob Grudet.

1:00:52

Thank you to both safety and vulnerability and those that can somehow have both at once.

1:00:57

Thanks to you for coming back from vacation.

1:00:59

Thank you, Joe.

1:01:00

I know you're going back on vacation quite soon.

1:01:04

And thanks to everyone who come, preemptively, who comes to our live show on Friday.

1:01:07

Yes.

1:01:08

We'll be very excited to see you there.

1:01:10

And we'll see you soon.

1:01:11

Bye.