Ep. 308 - Don't Argue the Call - the Definitive Conversation on "Out" Ball Disputes

2026-08-14 08:00:00 • 16:13

-

Hello and welcome to Pickleball Therapy. The podcast dedicated to your Pickleball improvement.

0:08

It's the only podcast dedicated to your mind. My name is Tony Roy. I'm the host of this

0:13

weekly podcast. It's a pleasure to be with you. This week's podcast, I am going to go

0:17

over with you the definitive guide to how to deal with out ball disputes. You're not

0:24

going to want to miss this episode of the podcast. It's got a lot of stuff in here to help

0:28

you process dealing with out ball disputes, but not just out ball disputes, life disputes,

0:34

because pickleball, mental journey translates to lifelong mental journey. It's good stuff.

0:40

And then in the riff, I'm going to give you a behind the scenes update on what's going

0:44

on with our new course here at Tony Roy Pickleball, which is my new home for all the coaching

0:51

and the work that I'm doing in pickleball. As we dive into the podcast, we have several

0:57

camps coming up. The Boston camp is either sold out or almost sold out. I'm not sure. I think

1:03

there's one player who may have a spot reserved on that one. So that one may be sold out by now.

1:08

Chicago is starting to move. We again, a lot of increase about Chicago. So if you're in the midwest,

1:13

interested in joining us for a camp, Chicago, October, let's do it. The Dallas camp is starting

1:20

to get filled up. So if you're interested in that Dallas camp, definitely check that one out.

1:24

And then we have several camps here in my home base here in Tampa, which is beautiful all time

1:28

a year. It's a little hot right now, but it's still beautiful. But certainly in the, when the

1:32

camps are scheduled, the temperature down here is going to be, we always say that's a reasonably

1:36

living Florida. So if you're interested in pickleball camp, make sure you check those out.

1:41

All right. Let's talk about out balls and out balls, specifically out ball disputes. How do you

1:45

deal with that when there's an out ball dispute? And let's go ahead and set the stage. Let's make

1:50

it spicy. Let's make it interesting. Score is 10, 9, 2. Your team is serving, of course, at 10,

1:58

9, 2. You got a volley. You hit the volley. Chris, you love it. Everything's great. It's right there.

2:07

It's right on the line. It's either, you know, a hair's breath in or a hair's breath out and your

2:12

opponent calls it out. What do you do in that situation? How do you deal with it? What's the right

2:18

what's the right approach? Again, you hit the ball. You think it, it's in or might be in, but let's

2:24

even go. You think it's in. You're 100% sure that ball is in. Your opponent calls it out. Very close

2:29

to the line. Though not something at six inches in. What do you do? So let's go through several

2:34

different ways of approaching this. And I think by the end, I think you'll agree with the premise that

2:39

we're, we're going to land on here. Let's start here. Who created the situation? Okay. So you're,

2:47

you're, you and your opponents. And I'm assuming most of the time, most of the time you're playing

2:52

with friends, right? That's, that's who your opponents are. So you now have a situation.

2:59

You hit the ball. They've called it out. You don't like it. Who created the situation?

3:07

The answer is you did. You did because you hit the ball. Very close to the line. One way or the

3:16

other inside or out could be in could be out. Right? So if you created the situation,

3:22

why not take some agency? Right? Why not take some ownership over that situation? And when you think

3:29

about it, you know, when you, when you think about it a little bit more broadly, right? You really

3:34

put your friends in a tough spot. Right? You hit the ball so close to the line that you're putting

3:40

them in an impossible situation to make a call. And unless you think they're affirmatively cheating

3:48

you, they're probably making the call actually not probably unless you believe they're firmly cheating

3:54

you, they are making the call the best way that they can. Right? They are actually doing the,

3:59

the best that they can in the situation that who created that you created. So let's start from

4:06

that premise, right? We created the situation. Maybe we shouldn't get all bent out of shape

4:10

because we don't like the call at the end of the day. Another thing to think about here is

4:16

where's this conversation going? Right? Your opponent says out. What's your next play? What's your

4:23

next move? Are you sure? Or you can say, I saw it in or okay, and then what happens next? Let's

4:30

play, let's play through it, right? They're just gameplay it a little bit. What are they supposed to

4:35

say? No, I saw it out. And then what are you going to say? No, I saw it in. Right? You're just going

4:41

to keep going with you and escalate. Even if you don't escalate, what's happened already? The minute

4:46

you challenge them, what happened to the temperature on the court, to the enjoyable time you were having

4:51

with your friends out on the pickleball court, how's that? How's that going for you? Right? So just

4:55

think about what happens when you initiate that conversation, what's already happened, and where

5:01

you going with it? Right? How far are you going to go with it? Are you going to back down? Are you

5:05

going to make them back down? Is somebody going to have to back down on this court or else we're going

5:08

to have, I don't know, fist to cuffs words? I'm not sure. So where are you going with the conversation?

5:13

Next question is, is there enough writing on this? Like is it sufficiently important

5:20

to win this particular point? And in this case, this particular game, to

5:26

create this unpleasantness on the court, to take a stand, is this the hill that we're dying on

5:34

this hill right here, right now? In a situation, going back to what we talked about earlier,

5:39

that we created a situation where we put our friends in a tough spot, is this the moment?

5:45

Is this important enough to us to like spend that capital of ours and potentially burn a

5:52

relationship? Potentially, it's definitely damage a relationship, even if it's a small damage,

5:55

there's damage. Is it that important? Is it enough writing on it?

6:01

The next one is, are you 100% sure you're right? I know you think you are. I get it, right?

6:07

Are you 100% sure you're right? Would you bet your life on it? I'm going to bet you wouldn't

6:12

bet your life on it. Actually, I was doing some clipping earlier today, some video clipping,

6:16

and I'm going to post a little short about this, serve. I actually cropped it in. It was called

6:22

out by opponents, right? It was like right there on the line. To me, it's a toss up. I wouldn't bet,

6:29

either in or out. I wouldn't bet my life on it being in. I wouldn't bet my life on it being out.

6:34

I don't know. And I cropped into it with the video tools that I have. I cropped into it. I looked

6:39

at it. I mean, the ball's, if it's in, it's in by a smidge. If it's out, it's out by a smidge.

6:45

And I wouldn't bet a dollar on that call. And so when you have these situations again that you

6:51

created, that conversation, I go on anywhere except negativity, are you even 100% sure that you're

6:57

right? It's a tough one, right? And if we're going to be rule specific, right? Because I can hear

7:05

some of the thinking already out there, I think I can hear thinking. Some of you may respond to

7:12

this by saying, well, those are the rules. The rules are the rules and if it's in, it's in,

7:15

it's out. It's out, right? All right. If we want to play by the rules, who's call is it?

7:21

What do the rules say about that? Who gets to make the call there? You're opponent. Not you,

7:27

they're call. And remember, going back to the, if you will, the original sin or the root cause,

7:34

the situation was created by us. The rules say it's their decision what the call is. So,

7:41

you know, so that's another strike against the against arguing. And then the last one I'll tell you

7:47

is what let's flip it around. Okay. They're serving at 1092. You're at the baseline. They hit the

7:54

ball. You call it out. How do you feel when they create a problem for you when they come at you

8:02

because they don't like your call? How does that make you feel as a pickable player and just as a

8:06

human being? Probably not great, right? Challenging your veracity, challenging your call,

8:13

challenging the situation that they could challenge you in a situation that you had,

8:16

nothing to do with, but you weren't the initial, initial perpetrator. You weren't the initial

8:21

cause or of the situation. They were, they hit the darn ball right there next to the line.

8:28

So, what do you do? Right? How do you feel? I'm guessing not good. So, when you think about the

8:34

litany of ways you can come at this, right? I think the answer is pretty apparent, I think,

8:41

which is when you have an outball dispute, when you have an outball,

8:48

any kind of disagreement about an out call situation, you got to move on. You just got to move on.

8:54

Then nothing happened, you know? You hit the ball. They call it out. Don't even hesitate. Don't

9:00

pause. Don't look at them a second time. Don't do anything like that. Don't elevate the

9:04

temperature in the room because you will elevate the temperature. If there's any indication that

9:08

you have a problem with the call, you just say, oh, man, I missed it. Toss in the ball. They're served,

9:15

carry on with life. Do not get bogged down with these calls. It's just a not a good investment of

9:21

time, energy, friend capital, all the factors are against challenging perceived injustices in

9:34

the out-call world. And I would submit to you, that's, to me, it's the same in tournament or

9:42

in competitive play and in rec play. So, tournaments, tournaments, league play, things like that.

9:49

Now, if you have a referee in a tournament, I have no problem with an appeal. I have no

9:53

problem with an appeal, because an tournament play, that's what the referees are for. You make the

9:58

appeal. The referees can't overrule it. Oftentimes, the cantaloupe is looking at the Nambali's

10:03

online. You just move on. There's no money in getting bogged down in a conversation about that.

10:09

In fact, if you watch any pro matches, they don't really get into it with each other. They just

10:13

use their challenge, right? They're not even sure. They're professionals. There's referees on the

10:19

court who aren't even sure. I can tell you sitting in the commentating booth, we'll watch it on the

10:23

screen as they're replaying it and they're zooming in on it, cropping in on it and showing it bigger

10:28

and bigger and bigger. Me and my fellow commentator will be like, I don't know, what'd you use?

10:33

They'll say it and I'll say it and I'll say it and they'll say, we can't tell either.

10:38

Why are we expecting more from our friends on Wednesday morning or on a Tuesday evening game

10:45

for them to have this eagle eye and if they didn't see it perfectly, then what,

10:49

their cheaters or something? You got to move past that. I'm going to tell you this way of thinking

10:55

about it. Is it worth the cost? Is this significant enough for me? Where's the conversation going

11:02

to go? Game playing that? Are you 100% sure that you're right about it? Flipping it around,

11:07

how would you feel? All those different techniques that we use or questions that we asked,

11:12

regarding outpoles, guess where you can use that too? In life. When you have a disagreement,

11:17

when you have an uncomfortable situation, when you have something that you're going to make an

11:21

issue of in your personal life, outside of pickleball, why not use the same filters, the same screens

11:29

to get to whether it's something that you should, in fact, or not should, but that you want to

11:35

articulate that you want to bring forward. It's just a really helpful way of reducing

11:44

unnecessary conflict in situations when it's not warranted. I'll call disputes on a pickleball

11:50

court. The dispute is never, ever, ever warranted under any circumstances, even in competitive play.

11:59

You make the appeal. That's not a dispute. Just make the appeal and you're done. No disputes on

12:03

that. Hopefully that helps you navigate outpoles and keep the temperature down the court. Just

12:11

remember why you're there. You let it play pickleball. See your friends and hopefully have a good time.

12:16

All right. Let's dive into the rift. I want to give you an update on what's going on behind the

12:19

scenes here at Tony work pickleball, what we're up to. I want to let you know that right now

12:25

been working a tail off on the most comprehensive course in pickleball. This is the course that's

12:33

going to have everything that you need, both step by step, as well as on your own if you want to

12:40

DIY it, basically you want to kind of navigate yourself. It's going to have the answers to your

12:44

questions because it's not just going to have like in this situation do this and this is

12:49

a situation do that, right? It's going to have this is how the situations are built. This is how

12:54

the framework of the game works given those situations so that you learn how to navigate the game

13:00

on your own. You become your own basically pilot, your own master inside the sport of pickleball

13:04

as opposed to just trying to remember what what did Tony say in this lesson or what had happened

13:09

but what did I read over here? What did I see over there? So if you you know most of many of you are

13:15

not most of you already know that I've developed a lot of pickleball curriculum in the past,

13:20

developed the most comprehensive camp and online curriculum courses that are out there in the past.

13:25

I can tell you that this one is even more thorough and more it's updated and it's just structured.

13:31

It has the benefit of my additional years of coaching so this program is going to be really powerful

13:40

and I already kind of alluded this a little bit about how it works basically is going to train you

13:44

but here's an initial premise that I think is really important to understand about the way that I

13:49

think about coaching but also the way that I would submit to you that you may want to consider

13:54

thinking about for your development as a player and so the the the whole course starts from the premise

14:00

that you are a capable intelligent adult human being. Okay. What that means is that you can learn how

14:09

to navigate pickleball yourself. Yes, I can guide you and the TRP coaching team can guide

14:18

but you're the one on the court. You're the one making decisions in real time. You're the one

14:22

deciding shots and strategies. You're the one picking the shots that you want to focus on and

14:26

things like that. That's going to be you and you're going to be empowered enough to do that

14:31

because the job of the course the way I see it is to transfer my pickleball knowledge and the

14:37

pickleball knowledge of the coaching team to you and this course course is kind of do that for sure.

14:44

I'm super excited to unveil the course that will be unveiled in September to the general public.

14:48

If you're on our email list you already got notified in the coaching digest but if you're

14:52

interested in early access you can just click on there there's a link that'll take you to the

14:56

founding information and you can decide if that's right for you. If you haven't seen the coaching

15:00

digested digested it's in your inbox. If you haven't received the coaching digest and you believe

15:04

you're on the email list send us an email support at 20workpickable.com. We'll get us sorted out. If

15:08

you're not on the email list you want to be go to 20workpickable.com. Join the email list. It is

15:13

free to join the email list and you also join the community for free and get some free courses.

15:17

A lot of good content on there for you. This is really important to me. I want to give a big

15:25

shout out and a big thanks to those of you who have joined the founding community here at 20work

15:31

pickable. You are the players who make this coaching, all the coaching including this podcast possible

15:38

and it means a lot to me personally that you've shown faith in the project and in what we're doing

15:46

and it without you again it wouldn't be possible and really appreciate it. I look forward to seeing

15:53

some of you in I think a couple weeks in Boston and then a few others of you up in Chicago and a

16:00

month or so and for everybody else I'll see you next week on the next regular episode of Pickable Therapy.