Erin Brockovich Is Taking On Data Centers

2026-10-03 09:55:00 • 1:10:03

-

Offline is brought to you by Zbiotics Pre-Alcohol.

0:04

You guys know how much I love Zbiotics.

0:06

All of us do here.

0:08

It works.

0:09

You take it before you have a couple drinks and you feel a lot better the next day and

0:16

that's all there is to it.

0:18

I can tell you all the other stuff they have here about how it works and I will.

0:22

But all you should know is every single person who's asked me about Zbiotics and has tried

0:26

it based on what I've said in these ads has come back and said, oh my god, it works.

0:32

You were right.

0:33

Zbiotics Pre-Alcohol probiotic drink is the world's first genetically engineered probiotic.

0:37

It was engineered by PhD microbiologist to break down Asselteldehyde, an unwanted byproduct

0:42

of alcohol metabolism and a word I can never pronounce.

0:45

Make Pre-Alcohol your first drink of the night drink responsibly and enjoy your next day activities.

0:50

Zbiotics is sold more than 14 million bottles and earned the trust of thousands including

0:55

us.

0:56

Try for yourself today and if you are unsatisfied they will refund your entire order.

1:00

No questions asked at dazbiotics.com slash offline code offline for 15% off your first order

1:07

that Zbiotics.com slash offline code offline.

1:11

Boo!

1:13

Spooky season has officially entered the group chat and that means one thing.

1:16

It's time to stock the fridge and summon your squad with smear not thighs.

1:20

Whether you're headed to a costume party hosting a scary movie marathon or laying low with

1:24

a backyard bonfire, smear smear always delivers.

1:28

And honestly, being the friend who remember to bring the drinks is elite behavior.

1:32

So skip the tricks and get the party started with a treat that's cold, crisp and perfectly

1:37

mixed.

1:38

And hey, if you're looking to switch things up, check out smear not thighs zero sugar.

1:42

Same flavors you love with zero sugar and a hundred calories.

1:46

Game changer.

1:47

Smear not thighs.

1:48

Two crisp to resist.

1:49

Please enjoy responsibly.

1:51

Must be 21+.

1:53

If you're like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium.

1:56

It's destroying.

1:57

Athlete, creator and YouTube Maxor.

2:00

YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads

2:04

so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym.

2:08

So no Wi-Fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day.

2:11

Plus, I get ad free videos, background play and so much more.

2:15

YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains.

2:18

Try YouTube Premium for 2 months free at youtube.com slash premium.

2:23

Hey, what's up guys?

2:24

It's Haley Bailey.

2:25

Okay, I need to tell you about something.

2:26

I just got YouTube Premium.

2:28

It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads so I can download my favorite videos

2:32

before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi.

2:35

Because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst.

2:37

I get ad free, I get background play and there's like a ton more in there.

2:41

You should try it.

2:42

If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium.

2:44

So try YouTube Premium for 2 months free at youtube.com slash premium.

2:48

Try eligibility varies.

2:50

Terms apply.

2:51

Anytime.

2:52

That's a mouthful.

2:53

I created Brockovich Data Center.

2:56

First day at Crash Twice.

2:57

By day three, every state was reporting.

3:01

Multiple cities, multiple counties, and every single state in the United States of America.

3:06

And that's my way.

3:07

Oh no, I'm cut full circle again.

3:09

I'm like, oh no.

3:11

And we're going to end up with a real sh** show here in about five years.

3:15

When technologies change, you're going to abandon these little mini Chernobles across

3:19

America.

3:20

It really does bother me that someone says, I'm on a fixed income.

3:26

And now I have to choose whether I eat or I pay my electric bill.

3:31

I'm sure you've probably heard about there's a big pro data center party in Washington,

3:35

DC last weekend.

3:36

I did, it's so bad.

3:37

They can have all their fun at those parties.

3:39

But I invite you to come, bring your tent.

3:43

We're going to stay by one of these data centers, okay?

3:46

Yeah.

3:47

And you're going to live it for a while and see what kicks in for you.

3:50

This isn't about stopping innovation.

3:51

Again, this is about where you're building it, how you're building it, and what has to

3:56

go along with that.

3:57

This is our land.

3:58

This is our water.

4:01

This is our future.

4:02

This is our sanctuary.

4:04

And it's just all at stake at once.

4:06

It is possible to have innovation.

4:08

But we cannot have it at the expense of humanity.

4:20

DC's hottest party last weekend was called Data After Dark and it had everything.

4:26

Tech Bros and Metaglasses, dancing Bitcoin miners, neoliberal kick streamers, AI photo booths,

4:32

and a Bitcoin sponsored whiskey activation all packed into a crypto founders bar, along

4:38

with hundreds of other people who seemed pretty horny for data centers.

4:41

I'm a DC's pro data center party and I'm asking why people love data centers?

4:46

Because I love the internet and it allows me to be on the internet.

4:49

It's ridiculous to be against them and I'd rather have them here than in China.

4:52

And there's only one engine that can propel the S&P 500 to even greater heights in that

4:59

data center.

5:00

That's compute.

5:01

Why do I love data centers?

5:03

My mother and my father met at a data center and so if the data center wasn't here, neither

5:07

would I.

5:08

It's hard to argue with that.

5:09

But apparently, if you're not in love with data centers or haven't fallen in love with

5:13

anybody who works at one, there's something wrong with you.

5:16

We cannot be the stupid people that chase them out.

5:18

If you want to be poor, have no jobs, you would be killing the golden goose.

5:23

When I look at Bernie Sanders and talk about data centers, so you actually want people

5:28

to die of cancer.

5:29

Or maybe you've just been brainwashed by China.

5:31

Tell why do people don't want them in their back here?

5:33

You know, a lot of people say that it's a China PR thing.

5:36

There's foreign sideops campaigns going on trying to get the US to stop building power

5:41

to get us to stop building data centers.

5:43

It is a Chinese sideop.

5:44

I really believe that.

5:45

It's not a conspiracy theory.

5:46

I think they're pushing those ideas.

5:48

Of course, one other possibility, just throwing this out there, is that people actually have

5:53

questions and concerns.

5:55

That's what Aaron Brockovich found out earlier this year when she woke up one morning to a

5:58

few dozen emails from people she'd never met.

6:01

They all lived in the same Pennsylvania town, and they were all worried about data centers,

6:06

which was weird because Aaron Brockovich, who's crusade against a company that had exposed

6:11

hundreds of people to toxic waste inspired the Oscar-winning movie, didn't know that much

6:15

about data centers.

6:17

But instead of assuming these people were crazy, Aaron decided to listen to them.

6:21

She put out a call for anyone who was concerned about a data center in their community to tell

6:26

her about it.

6:27

Her website crashed twice on the first day.

6:30

Within a month, she'd received nearly 4,000 submissions from people who were worried about

6:34

water, about noise, about pollution, and their electric bills, and their homes, and their

6:39

neighborhoods.

6:40

But the most common complaint was that no one had even told them what was happening.

6:44

Why was a massive data center being built before anyone in the community had heard about

6:48

it?

6:49

Why were they finding out after the permits had already been approved?

6:52

Why had local officials signed non-disclosure agreements?

6:55

If you haven't yet experienced what happens when a data center comes to town, you may

7:00

someday get the chance.

7:01

Like I do guess that a lot of the world gets covered in data centers over time.

7:05

Which is already happening.

7:07

Data centers already power most of modern life.

7:09

With Google search, Netflix stream, Zoom call, cloud backup, and increasingly, every interaction

7:15

with artificial intelligence.

7:17

But AI requires a lot more computing power, which requires a lot more data centers.

7:22

In just four years, data centers are estimated to consume nearly 12% of all the electricity

7:27

generated in the United States.

7:30

More than 100 are currently under construction, and the AI companies already have plans to

7:35

build hundreds more.

7:36

They're taking over farmland and forests in rural areas and small towns, huge amounts

7:41

of land, hundreds of acres, millions of square feet.

7:45

Metis next data center will be almost twice as big as Central Park.

7:50

Some of those buildings are absolutely beautiful.

7:52

They're big and they're big, strong, powerful buildings, but they're beautiful, and they

7:57

add greatly to a community.

7:59

The president also said, and I quote, I would like to have data centers.

8:03

It doesn't mean I want them right next to my house, but certainly I like them in my

8:08

county.

8:09

Well, sure.

8:10

Imagine living next to one of these hyper scale data centers.

8:13

They run all day and night.

8:15

Their generators and cooling systems can create constant noise and air pollution.

8:20

Depending on where and how they're built, these data centers can consume enormous amounts

8:24

of water.

8:25

And because they also consume enormous amounts of electricity, data centers can require

8:29

billions in new power plants, transmission lines, substations, pipelines, generators,

8:36

cost that can end up on everyone else's utility bills.

8:39

Which is why the vast majority of Americans aren't sold on data centers.

8:44

Democrats, independence, Republicans, you see it in every poll, no matter how the question

8:48

is asked.

8:49

There's more common ground on data centers than almost any other issue in politics right

8:53

now.

8:54

Most Americans aren't comfortable with data centers being built in their communities.

8:58

They think they're bad for the environment, bad for their utility bills, and bad for

9:02

their quality of life.

9:03

But the response from people who want to build these data centers, who have the power and

9:07

money to make that happen, is to dismiss these concerns as stupid or manufactured or evidence

9:13

of a Chinese sia.

9:14

They think that if you have questions about the giant construction project that suddenly

9:18

appear down the street, you're suffering from some kind of psychosis, which is the word

9:23

used by the very same people who just threw a data center party with cocktails named

9:28

after small nuclear reactors and water cooling systems.

9:32

Telling someone they're mentally ill isn't usually the most persuasive argument.

9:36

Which is unfortunate because there are legitimate reasons to build data centers and to do it

9:41

in ways that mitigate people's concerns and actually benefit communities.

9:46

It is possible, for example, to design data centers that use dramatically less water and

9:51

run on clean energy.

9:52

It's possible to make AI companies pay for the extra power they use and pay to upgrade

9:57

the electric grid instead of quietly sending the bill to everyone else.

10:02

It's possible to make them pay communities billions of dollars in taxes instead of giving

10:06

them billions of dollars in tax cuts.

10:10

Loudoun County, Virginia, which has more data centers than anywhere in the world, gets

10:14

an enormous amount of revenue from these companies that's funded brand new schools and roads

10:18

and parks.

10:19

But this only happens if people and their elected representatives demand it.

10:24

And they can only do that if they know about these data center projects before they get

10:28

built and have a say over how they get built and where and on what turns.

10:32

The most revealing thing about the thousands of complaints Aaron Brockovich has received

10:36

hasn't just been people worried about water or electricity or noise.

10:40

It's how many people have told her how powerless they felt.

10:43

Like something enormous was happening where they live and they had no control over it.

10:47

We have now lived through several decades of enormous technological change in economic

10:52

upheaval that are always explained to us as inevitable.

10:56

Factories moving overseas, jobs getting automated, communities becoming hollowed out, tech

11:01

companies stealing our privacy and our kids childhood, social media breaking all of our brains

11:07

again and again.

11:08

People who run these companies and our government tell us that this is all just the price of progress.

11:14

Even when the people who pay the highest price don't get much of a say in how that progress

11:18

happens.

11:20

Now they're saying the same thing about AI, promising medical breakthroughs and automated

11:24

agents and lives of leisure to people who can barely afford housing and have no idea whether

11:29

their jobs will even exist in this new world.

11:32

So yeah, people are going to be pissed when they're told about the giant noisy buildings

11:36

going up down the street that require massive amounts of water and electricity.

11:40

They may have to foot the bill for people are sick of being told that the future is something

11:45

that happens to them.

11:47

In a democracy, we all deserve the chance to shape the forces that shape our lives.

11:52

And that's what the activism around data centers is all about.

11:55

That's why all across the country, these AI companies are finally being forced to stop

12:00

and listen and negotiate with people over land and water and utility rates before they're

12:05

granted the privilege of operating in our communities.

12:09

That's not standing in the way of progress.

12:11

That's making sure everyone benefits from it.

12:14

Because the future shouldn't be something that a few powerful people get to decide for

12:18

everyone else.

12:20

It belongs to all of us.

12:22

My guest this week is Erin Brockovich, who spent more than three decades helping communities

12:26

take on some of the biggest corporations and environmental fights in the country.

12:30

She's not a scientist or a lawyer and she'd probably be the first person to tell you that.

12:35

Her superpower has always been listening to people, asking questions and helping them

12:39

figure out how to fight for themselves.

12:41

Her latest fight over data centers is based on what she's found after hearing from thousands

12:45

of people across the country.

12:47

And it's a lot more complicated, more interesting too than the usual debates over whether these

12:52

things are just good or bad.

12:54

So I wanted to talk to her about what she's learned, which concerns are real, what the

12:57

industry gets wrong about the backlash, and whether there's a way to build what we need

13:02

without screwing over the people who have to live with it.

13:05

Here's Erin Brockovich.

13:09

Welcome to the show.

13:11

Hello.

13:12

Thanks for having me.

13:13

It's great to be here.

13:14

It's great to have you.

13:16

I want to spend most of our time talking about your work on data centers, but because it's

13:21

connected, I'd love to start by going back to where all this started for you in Henkley,

13:25

California.

13:27

Before the lawsuits and the movie and Julia Roberts, you were a file clerk who noticed

13:32

medical records mixed in with real estate documents.

13:37

What made you look at that and think something isn't right here?

13:42

So that's a great beginning question because not to get off track.

13:47

I'll come right back to it when I started the data centers.

13:51

When it first happened, I was like, oh no, I've just come full circle.

13:56

Well, that's what made me think about it.

13:58

Back in Henkley, California.

13:59

So that was a great question.

14:03

And Edmazery brought me the file way back in the day.

14:06

I was 31 years old, single mom of three.

14:10

And he put the file on my desk.

14:11

He asked me to open a PI file.

14:14

And he said, you know how to do that.

14:15

And I'm like, yeah, sure, which I didn't know.

14:18

So I thought, I better go through the box.

14:20

And I like, I'm very curious.

14:22

And I oftentimes self-taught.

14:25

And I'm like, I better teach myself exactly what it is he wants.

14:29

And so as I was opening files, I was curious about one in particular.

14:35

And it was medical records.

14:37

And it was done in blood test draws on a blood chart.

14:41

So it was pretty easily for me to see, first of all, why are medical records in a real

14:47

estate, pro bono real estate case?

14:50

Okay, that's interesting.

14:52

But what really interested me was the bar graph.

14:54

So it was, you know, off to the left.

14:56

It was T cells and red cells and white counts and all of that.

15:00

And every one of them was like, you could just see off the chart.

15:03

You could just see where they were being flagged.

15:05

And that's odd.

15:07

But what even peaked my curiosity further was every one of the medical records, the names

15:12

of the child and their ages were there.

15:14

And I'm like, why would children this young?

15:19

If these were my kids, I'd want to know what's wrong.

15:23

And so that's what really started my curiosity was those medical records of children.

15:29

Now obviously data centers aren't chromium contamination.

15:34

But when you started, when you started hearing from communities about data centers, what

15:40

did you recognize from the fights that you've been involved in before?

15:45

Like what sort of said, oh, this is maybe a come full circle?

15:48

Ever since the film came out, you know, when there's a big environmental problem, I get

15:52

emails.

15:53

When I get emails all the time, but when I get them in clusters, 15, 30, 40, 50 from

15:59

the same town, that generally is my first clue, something's going on.

16:06

So I woke up, when we do the map starting May five, six months ago, there was 30 individual

16:14

emails from a community in Pennsylvania.

16:17

And they were all reporting issues, anger, lack of transparency about data centers.

16:24

Look, data centers have been around for decades.

16:27

We all know, you know, about the cloud and stuff.

16:30

I'm like, that's all.

16:32

And so what is going on in this town?

16:34

And what's up with data centers?

16:36

Because you know, it was AI hyper scale data centers.

16:41

So I started researching it.

16:43

This is interesting.

16:45

Now I like to see the big picture and I like to do maps because I can see the big picture.

16:51

So I thought, huh, this is feeling like kingly because you're learning about data centers,

16:56

utility companies, electricity, water consumption.

17:01

Somebody is hiding something.

17:02

I'm like, oh, no, am I going to do this?

17:04

I'm like, I wonder if it's just this town.

17:06

So I created Brockovich data center and launched it.

17:11

I did it twice.

17:13

By day three, every state was reporting multiple cities, multiple counties and every single

17:20

state in the United States of America.

17:22

And that's when I went, oh, no, I'm cut full circle again.

17:26

I'm like, oh, no.

17:28

And what really stood out for me, again, where I came full circle.

17:37

I remembered distinct, kingly, so well, I'm like, uh, somebody's lying about something

17:41

somewhere.

17:43

Every single submission, every single submission from every county, every city, every state

17:49

was all done under non disclosure.

17:51

And I'm like, wait, how does that happen?

17:55

So that is how it started.

17:58

What was the, um, the tenor of the complaints or the concerns that you were receiving from

18:05

people?

18:06

Also, as they first started coming in and they're still to this day, it's all about non

18:12

disclosure.

18:13

I tell you something that I learned, not only in hinkly, but every single community I've

18:18

been involved in.

18:21

They like to be heard.

18:24

They like to have a voice.

18:26

They are cooperative.

18:28

They want to see the table.

18:29

They want to have a conversation and they want to know what's going on.

18:33

So if you're transparent with them, they work with you, but the minute you hide from

18:39

them or conceal from them or lie from them, the game changes.

18:45

And that's exactly what was happening.

18:48

So as information comes in, I like to work in silos.

18:53

So we started because the submissions range from proposal.

18:57

We're in the fight stage.

18:59

We're in the cover-up stage.

19:01

And then submissions were coming in.

19:02

We're in the construction phase.

19:04

And then submissions coming in up and running.

19:07

So I can kind of run what's going on from proposal through construction to up and running.

19:14

And just to dig into the NDAs, right?

19:17

Because you said that like the number one concern, you know, wasn't actually water or electricity

19:22

or noise, that that's part of it.

19:24

But it's this transparency.

19:25

It was right behind it.

19:26

Right.

19:27

But this transparency issue.

19:29

And like how common are NDAs between local governments and developers?

19:34

I guess it could happen one-offs here and there.

19:37

But this is where I'm like going, wait a minute.

19:40

How I'm looking at this whole picture.

19:43

How did every one of these at the same time get put under NDAs?

19:49

Different states, different permits, different regulations and rules and all of that.

19:53

That's what really surprised me.

19:56

It was so secretive.

19:58

Now communities and people underestimate communities often.

20:02

They are smart.

20:05

They want answers.

20:07

And again, another thing that I started seeing from them pretty early on was they were

20:12

doing FOIA requests, freedom of information requests.

20:16

And multiple states, people were reporting from their FOIA requests that the NDAs were

20:23

signed in 2021 and 2022.

20:25

I'm like, oh.

20:28

Oh.

20:29

So you know, I could really go down a rabbit hole here.

20:32

What's going on?

20:33

I was going to say, what have you learned about why the NDAs were signed and why the companies

20:42

that want to build these hyper scale data centers want NDAs to be signed?

20:47

Is it they are doing something secrets that they don't want people to find out about?

20:53

Is it that they just don't want to go through the messy process of democracy and local input

21:00

and having people, you know, having conversations about this or what is it?

21:05

I think it's all of the above.

21:06

Sure, because I think they priority.

21:08

You know, we come in here and you know, we're going to rip up 3,500 acres and create this

21:13

massive noise and destruction of wildlife and your sanctuary and drop your property values

21:18

and raise your utility bills and you're going to worry about your health.

21:21

Now, maybe we should keep it on the low down.

21:24

I will say that shortly after this started and the public opposition started to get really

21:29

big, Microsoft removed all of its NDAs.

21:32

Now a little too late for that because now people really don't trust you.

21:36

But I think that there was, you know, they're going to cite national security reasons, but

21:41

as you get further and further into this and I learn more and more information as this

21:46

goes on, that on the NDA side is there changing ordinances.

21:56

So I've had many communities report.

21:59

I just got a submission out of Florida that really startled me.

22:03

That the developer is writing and rewriting the zoning ordinances for the city council.

22:10

I'm like, whoa.

22:14

And they're writing the ordinances for the PUC.

22:16

I'm like, whoa.

22:18

How the hell is this going on?

22:20

So I think that is what the NDAs were about because they didn't want people to know.

22:27

They are changing zoning ordinances.

22:30

They're doing all of that.

22:32

And if you're open about that, people are going to say, whoa, wait a minute.

22:39

So it was a surprise attack.

22:41

I hate to even use that word, but it feels that way to people because now that when they

22:46

do get notices, it's too late.

22:47

Everything's already been signed.

22:48

They're like, what is happening here?

22:50

So I think there's a lot of reasons why they want to keep it secret.

22:53

And it could be about, you know, water consumption or utilities.

22:58

It could be about we're going to rezone this and we're going to rezone agricultural land.

23:05

If you give people a heads up, you're going to get an immediate resistance.

23:09

I don't think they saw this type of public opposition coming.

23:13

And what about the local officials that signed these NDAs and approved these projects?

23:19

Like, what were they getting out of it?

23:21

What have they been getting out of it?

23:22

Money, you know, they come in with all this kind of money.

23:24

So we've got to look at, you know, we're talking about the biggest corporations with the

23:28

most money in the entire world.

23:31

And so when you come in and most data centers historically, again, data centers, we are

23:37

now talking about AI hyper scale data centers.

23:41

This is important, I think, because people think

23:43

data centers and they're like, okay, it's a building down the road and then they pay

23:47

some money in the community.

23:48

It's great.

23:49

But these are like massive now, right?

23:51

They are massive.

23:52

And it is for AI.

23:53

They are building these new data centers for artificial intelligence.

23:58

So data centers have been around for decades and they're normally more in the city.

24:03

And so with the AI hyper scale data centers and because they need so much land, guess what?

24:10

They're moving into rural zones.

24:12

So they're inside the infrastructure inside of America and all these rural locations in

24:18

Indiana and Ohio and Kansas and Missouri and Wisconsin and you name it and all the

24:24

sudden these AI hyper scale data centers have become the problem.

24:29

And these AI hyper scale data centers cannot function or operate without earth, without water,

24:39

without electricity, without copper.

24:41

And I think people think that the cloud is something just ethereal floating around out

24:48

there.

24:49

When it's actually the only way any of this work is tethered to the earth.

24:54

Yeah, it's servers.

24:56

Absolutely.

24:57

And those servers can't do their job without massive amounts of water and electricity.

25:03

So now these AI hyper scale data centers are exactly what public opposition is and exactly

25:10

what has set these communities off.

25:13

You have, you've just come in, they've had no say, they feel completely mowed over.

25:19

And you're, you're, we're not talking about one town, one community, one utility and one

25:27

aquifer.

25:28

We are now talking about these people that are coming up against the biggest people with

25:34

money around that is jeopardizing the water, the land, the air, their wildlife, their tourism,

25:46

their economic base, their sanctuaries and they're fearful for their future health.

25:52

So everything at once is at stake for them.

26:02

offline is brought to you by lean.

26:04

GLP1 injections have been the talk of the weight loss industry for years now and for good reason,

26:08

the result are dramatic.

26:10

They're powerful medications that work by lowering blood sugar and reducing appetite.

26:14

So what if you're looking to lose weight but not interested in painful weekly injections,

26:18

especially considering some of those intense side effects you've likely heard about?

26:22

Whether you're in pursuit of a personal fitness goal or want to refresh your daily wellness

26:25

routine, managing your weight can feel like an uphill battle.

26:29

That's why the team at Brickhouse Nutrition developed lean, a dietary supplement designed

26:33

to support your everyday health journey formulated with quality ingredients, lean help support

26:38

healthy blood sugar balance, aid metabolism and help manage cravings so you can feel

26:43

more in control of your daily routine.

26:45

Lean is designed for individuals looking for structured support on their dedicated weight

26:48

management journey, get started with 20% off and free rush shipping so you can add lean

26:53

to your healthy diet and exercise plan.

26:56

Take Lean.com and enter offline for your discount.

27:00

That's promo code offline at take lean dot com.

27:05

Offline is brought to you by FreshBooks.

27:07

Whether you just launched your service business or you've been at it for years, the money

27:10

side has a way of pulling you from the work you actually love doing.

27:14

FreshBooks changes that.

27:15

FreshBooks makes the financials of your service-based business easy.

27:19

Log your hours, send a branded invoice, get paid and know your numbers instead of chasing

27:22

them.

27:23

Money in, money out, all in one place.

27:25

No more juggling one app for clients and other for billing plus a pile of spreadsheets

27:29

and emails.

27:30

FreshBooks is designed for how small business owners think about money, not how an accountant

27:34

does.

27:35

You don't need a financial background to use FreshBooks.

27:36

It's simple on purpose.

27:38

Most owners are up and running in minutes, not days.

27:40

And if you need help, a real person is available on every plan.

27:44

FreshBooks has been trusted by service businesses for over 20 years, helping over 500,000 owners

27:48

and solo pro-ners run their business confidently.

27:51

Right now, my listeners can get FreshBooks for less than $3 a month, four-year first,

27:55

four months.

27:56

That's 90% off.

27:57

Head to FreshBooks.com slash podcast to get started.

28:00

That's 90% off under $3 a month for four months at FreshBooks.com slash podcast.

28:11

So I want to walk through for people like each of the different main areas of concerns

28:16

over data centers.

28:18

And let's start with the water.

28:21

When should people legitimately worry about a data center's water use and when are some

28:27

of the scarier numbers possibly misleading?

28:30

Generally, at that proposal phase, they're coming into late because they're finding out

28:36

too late.

28:37

And they're already started.

28:40

Everything's already signed.

28:41

So they're not really having a voice.

28:44

You just ask a question that they all want to ask.

28:47

Had they been included at that meeting?

28:49

I do not think it's unreasonable.

28:51

Look, I don't think this is about trying to stop innovation.

28:55

This is about where you're building them, how you're building them, what resources are

29:00

going to be taken without any type of questions.

29:04

They don't want you to ask questions.

29:05

And anybody, especially farmers and ranchers and people in those rural areas, that's the

29:11

first question that they would be asking you, okay, what kind of acreage are you looking

29:17

at?

29:18

What kind of aquifer are you going to be in?

29:20

What kind of water consumption are you going to be using?

29:24

Will it affect our livestock?

29:26

They would have naturally asked those questions, but they didn't get that chance.

29:31

And some people just literally were so left out.

29:34

They're all the sudden, they're like, what are they tearing all the trees down?

29:38

How different is a facility that uses evaporative cooling in like a drought prone community

29:45

from one using closed-loop cooling or recycled waste water?

29:51

So the closed-loop system, so there's a little wizardry going on here in the closed-loop

29:57

system.

29:58

Because it's for people who don't know, you always hear it.

30:01

Like, the response to concerns over water is, well, now they can design them so that they

30:06

are closed-loop, which for people who don't know is they can basically just use less water.

30:12

So they are just recycling the water or there's a water in a closed-loop.

30:16

And so the concerns about the water, it's actually small compared to all the kinds of, you

30:21

know, the amount of water, all kinds of other things in our lives use and machines and so

30:26

and the comparison to the golf courses.

30:28

Right, yeah, exactly.

30:29

They do, yeah, they use the golf course.

30:30

And so, you know, we've got closed-loop cooling and recycled waste water and now everything's

30:36

fine.

30:37

No.

30:38

Normally, you have like, like in a Hinkley, California, you have, you know, open air evaporation

30:43

that's on sites.

30:46

And so these, again, these AI hyperscale data centers, they would use a lot of water.

30:53

And there was a lot of opposition, as we know, about that water consumption.

30:57

So now it's the, we've gone to closed-loop and here's kind of your wizardry.

31:04

So yes, if you are not doing open air on site, you are saving water at that location.

31:11

But when you go off site, when you do closed-loop, you have and will possibly use more water

31:19

consumption off site because you now have to power electricity to all of the DCs, the

31:28

data centers.

31:30

And so what's happening is you're just, it's a trade-off.

31:35

You're not saving water.

31:36

You could actually be using more water consumption.

31:40

Water power is electricity and you've got to now get all this electricity to these data

31:44

centers.

31:45

So it's called the water electric paradox.

31:49

It has been a paradox.

31:51

Engineering hasn't figured it out forever because you're cannibalizing basically water

31:55

for electricity or one or the other.

31:58

So it's not necessarily saving water.

32:02

It is possibly going to consume more water off site.

32:07

And now we have, here comes the electricity side of it.

32:11

Here's another thing that people are starting to get enraged about.

32:15

All of these massive 765K volt lines that are coming through their property, they're

32:21

taking it by imminent domain.

32:24

And all these transmission lines, you've got to run power to the DC.

32:29

So you're either going to do it by firing up coal plants or new energy plants because

32:38

that's how you're going to get electricity.

32:40

So it's called the water electric paradox.

32:43

And it's really interesting because I was speaking at the UN in New York for climate

32:49

week.

32:50

And your sustainable developmental goals, SDG 6, which is water and SDG 7 are now in conflict

32:58

with each other.

33:00

And we can't cannibalize one or the other.

33:04

So I think there's a real mandate that we and these huge tech guys, you're shooting

33:10

everything off to space, you created this AI.

33:13

I don't know why you can't solve the water electric paradox.

33:18

Well, on the electricity issue, obviously you had a lot of concerns about that.

33:23

My understanding is that giant data centers don't have to raise everyone else's electric

33:29

bills, but that this is a regulatory choice about who pays for new generation and grid infrastructure.

33:37

And is that right?

33:39

Absolutely.

33:40

And so, you know, people, my gosh, you know, of all these submissions, it just really

33:46

bothers me when because now it looks like everything's going to get kicked off to us to

33:52

pay for.

33:54

That isn't the way this should be.

33:55

You want these AI, hyper scale data centers?

33:58

Hey, I think there should be oversight.

34:00

And I don't think it's unreasonable to do that at all.

34:04

You know, this is classic, big corporate behavior that just wants to kick the can down the

34:09

line for the sake of money.

34:11

And we're going to end up with a real shit show here in about five years when technology

34:16

has changed.

34:17

You're going to abandon these little mini Chernobles across America.

34:21

Why we can't get them on the upfront to pay for what they need to pay for and their

34:28

safety and their infrastructure.

34:30

And it should be their infrastructure.

34:32

Listen, we have an infrastructure out there that we all know is aged and antiquated.

34:37

It can't handle this.

34:38

And so people are worried about the cost coming to them and it's happening.

34:44

Now more and more states are getting involved, more and more, you know, local legislation

34:49

and things are coming out, even the state of Texas and Texas is a big situation going

34:55

on out there is said, wait a minute, I'm not even going to do anymore.

34:59

Allow this until we have an idea about the electricity and you're going to pay for it

35:05

and the consumers aren't.

35:06

But I have people writing to me already, their electricity bills and their water bills

35:10

are going up to to 400%.

35:14

And they're sending me before and after.

35:18

And to get emails, these submissions, it really does bother me that someone says, I'm on

35:27

a fixed income.

35:29

And now I have to choose whether I eat or I pay my electric bill.

35:35

I'm like, what is going on out there?

35:39

And so yeah, this is all the stuff that we kind of monitor in the arc.

35:43

And I will say here, you know, when I very first got involved and started doing a lot of

35:48

research and there was people out there already definitely grumbling around where you had

35:53

maybe 30 individual local areas looking at pauses, more toryms for a year.

36:04

Rare if you saw one that was a full on ban.

36:07

Those numbers are now over 600 since this public opposition started where people are definitely

36:16

starting, starting this conversation.

36:20

And some towns, listen, you voted them in.

36:23

We're going to vote you out.

36:24

Festus Missouri was one of the first towns to do that.

36:27

They just voted them all out.

36:28

I think they voted all the data centers.

36:30

Absolutely.

36:31

And kind of to answer your question, you asked earlier what's happening with these city

36:35

council members, they've never seen this kind of money come in.

36:41

And it's hard for them to turn away and go, well, you know, we could use this money for

36:46

schools or for, you know, parks or replacing what you've destroyed, which communities are

36:53

now reporting back.

36:54

They haven't done that at all.

36:56

But I do think at a city council level, it's really hard for them to overcome these

37:03

giant companies and the money that's involved.

37:07

And so sure, I'm going to sign an NDA, but the deeper you get into it, the city councils

37:13

in a ways are getting moved out because they're writing the city council ordinances.

37:17

They're doing and changing the rezoning.

37:20

And so it's hard for them.

37:22

But people are definitely opposing city councils.

37:29

They are firing in them.

37:31

They are getting them out of office.

37:33

I think we all saw what happened in Utah with Kevin O'Leary and that public opposition.

37:41

That was quite steep.

37:43

And eventually is, you know, the governor came in and he said, we're going to have to

37:46

just scale this back because of the public opposition.

37:49

But you remember, they just went through elections and their speaker, the house lost and all

37:53

those elder men that voted this in, they're gone.

37:56

So I think that these community members are really paying attention to what's going on

38:04

with their city councils and their local representatives and their state reps on these

38:10

data center situations.

38:12

And they, I think they're going to shift tracks.

38:16

They're very upset.

38:17

If the companies are forced to pay the full incremental cost of the electricity that they

38:26

did, the DC's need, including generation and grid upgrades and they use renewable energy.

38:35

Like how much of people's objections do you think dissipate?

38:39

Not a lot.

38:40

One, you're too late.

38:43

You're too late.

38:44

You already came in and full on secrecy with non-disclosures.

38:49

So now there's a situation where they don't trust you.

38:53

So is it trust them?

38:54

Yeah, absolutely.

38:56

Now they do not trust them.

38:59

And so I think there will be a hesitation.

39:01

I think the look at it, we should have, see, this is where I just don't understand companies

39:08

like this.

39:09

I don't know why you don't do with your problems on the front.

39:12

Yeah, we got away with that.

39:14

All of us have to change.

39:15

I think corporations need to change their business model.

39:19

And if you go back and look at what happened with the Ford Pinto theory, you know where

39:23

the gas tank was at the back.

39:24

Oh, yeah.

39:25

You got hit.

39:26

It would blow up.

39:27

Well, the company made a decision.

39:29

You know, it's more expensive to fix the line problem, right?

39:33

And it's cheaper to run it down the line.

39:34

And I think some corporations, if not a lot of them, have gone with that philosophy the

39:38

whole time.

39:39

None of this would have had to happen.

39:42

This backlash would have never happened.

39:43

Had these companies on the up front been honest and knocked, kicked this down the line

39:51

and been transparent.

39:53

There could have been a different outcome.

39:56

So now the people tend to not trust, but now they're going to talk about, okay, so you're

40:02

going to pay for electricity.

40:04

But it's the disruption to their land, the uncertainty about the closed loop and the

40:11

chemicals that are involved.

40:13

And what if there's a breach?

40:14

And we've already seen several breaches.

40:16

We've seen one in Wyoming, Cheyenne, Wyoming where they had a bad bacteria.

40:20

We just saw a breach with 5,000 gallons of diesel.

40:24

And it's again about electricity.

40:26

And some of these facilities are proposing 2,500 to 3,000 diesel generators.

40:33

So now these people have these monstrosities in their backyard.

40:37

Their wildlife has gone.

40:38

And the people that are very close to them and literally, it's not like they got an option

40:44

to show up at a city council and go, okay, we want a 20 mile buffer.

40:48

They didn't even get that.

40:50

These are literally in their backyards.

40:54

And they are loud.

40:57

Is this like being around?

40:58

I was going to ask about the noise.

40:59

It's, I can't tell you how many submissions we have of the headaches, that kind of decibel

41:08

24-7s.

41:11

There's no piece that the headaches, the anxiety, the problems that they're seeing with children,

41:18

the reports from ranchers about this high decibel is very concerning to them because it's

41:25

very stressful to the animals.

41:27

So ranchers are starting to report more stillbirths because it's very, very stressful for them.

41:34

And again, bringing in all these power lines, I've had more veterinarians, veterinarians

41:41

who have been taking care of livestock and dairy cattle for 35, 40, 45 years.

41:47

And what they're very concerned about is all these lines coming in and tell their grounded

41:55

to the DC, you can have stravalths everywhere.

41:58

And they have seen industries get wiped out from miles because of this.

42:04

So I guess that was, I can be long winded.

42:06

No, that's what I was going to ask about this all.

42:09

To come in now and ask these communities something different, I just, I probably, I think

42:15

they're going to go out now.

42:17

Yeah, I was watching this video that more perfect union did of this couple.

42:21

And the data center goes up right next to where they live.

42:25

And they're like, it goes all day and all night at night.

42:30

You can see the lights shining into their people's house every single night and the noise.

42:35

Yes.

42:36

At like two, three, four in the morning waking them up.

42:38

And it's like, that is wild.

42:41

It is.

42:42

There's nothing you can do about that.

42:43

And that just happens.

42:44

Right.

42:45

And they have no choice.

42:46

And believe me, nobody's going to want to be buying these houses.

42:50

And I have concerns from whistleblowers inside that are emailing me.

42:57

And things that they're building them with no permits.

42:59

I'm like, what?

43:00

I mean, things that you don't want to hear.

43:04

And they're, they're even reporting.

43:06

Listen, I may be the electrician in here, but this is going to be a year job.

43:10

And then I don't have a job.

43:12

And then it takes very few to actually once they're up and running, man it.

43:18

But now you've destroyed an area where you may have a lot of fly fishing or tourism goes

43:23

away or property values have gone down and they don't have a job.

43:27

So they're even reporting the idea that this is so economically great.

43:31

We don't see that happening.

43:33

So let's say someone hears tomorrow that a company wants to build a hyper scale AI data

43:40

center in their community.

43:42

Like, what should they be pushing their local officials to demand from that company?

43:48

Like what's the, what's the Aaron Brockovich checklist?

43:51

Well, a, what is the water consumption?

43:56

I mean, how many acres is this going to be?

43:59

What is the water consumption?

44:02

What's our buffer?

44:03

Are you a mile back?

44:05

Are you right up or asked?

44:06

Are you going to be 20 miles back?

44:09

What about electricity?

44:11

Build these big, you know, 765 cable transmission lines becoming through.

44:17

Those are the kind of questions that they need to know.

44:20

Is there a way to build it that you think, because they're going to get built, right?

44:26

And like, are there ways to build them that you think would satisfy a lot of the problems?

44:31

Even if people don't trust them, if, you know, there was, if tomorrow we can all wake

44:35

up and there were new laws passed and new regulations, like, what is the ideal way to

44:40

build these data centers?

44:43

That's a great question.

44:44

And one that always baths me because there is another way.

44:47

And there are other solutions.

44:49

What is this rush to have them done this way when, you know, that's interesting.

44:56

So again, I'm not about stopping innovation and these data centers don't have to be done

45:02

the way they're being done.

45:04

I get on AI.

45:06

I learned in Hinkley oftentimes can take kind of their own information and use it against

45:11

them for the right reason.

45:14

So I get on AI and I'm like, okay.

45:17

So everyone thinks you're so smart.

45:20

You tell me where you would build all the data centers in the United States.

45:26

And it wrote back if I had to redesign and how we built the data centers in the United

45:30

States, I do it based on one simple rule.

45:34

You wrote contact with human resources.

45:36

I'll get.

45:37

Now, you're all going to say, hey, I'm so smart.

45:40

Now, you're either going to listen to it or you're not.

45:42

Because you built it or you're going to be a hypocrite.

45:46

Which is it?

45:47

Because it's telling you no human resources.

45:50

So there are other solutions.

45:53

There are, let's talk about all the caverns that exist.

45:56

What about looking at building them underground?

46:00

Where it's dark and cool and water and isn't going to interfere with the land and the

46:08

transmission lines and electric bills?

46:11

I've read many articles.

46:12

Maybe you have two about Samsung that's putting them out on barges and using the waves as

46:18

energy and keeping them up and in the cool climates up north where it's drizzly and overcast

46:25

because that's what they need.

46:29

There are other solutions.

46:31

There are conversations being had about building them smaller where like the size of your

46:37

Mac laptop right there, everybody could have one of those on the outside of their house.

46:43

So smaller underground in locations where, and first of all, we're building these things

46:51

that are water hogs and electricity hogs on two-thirds of the United States is in a huge

46:56

drought.

46:57

Yeah.

46:58

And that makes no sense, either.

46:59

So there are other solutions and other options.

47:03

I think that will be coming down the line and we're going to look back on go, why the hell

47:07

do we even get put through this exercise?

47:10

Because they will possibly, these massive AI hyperscale data centers will be obscure.

47:18

Like how many times have we got upgrades on our phones?

47:21

I mean, they're changing constantly.

47:24

So that's the thing that gets my go.

47:26

There are solutions to it.

47:36

Offline is brought to by Quince.

47:37

We're officially back in the full swing of fall and all of the busyness that entails.

47:42

When it comes to getting dressed in the morning, most of us are looking for high quality pieces

47:44

we can throw on without thinking too hard and still look great.

47:48

The sweater that goes with everything, the perfect pair of pants or a no-fail t-shirt

47:52

that stands up to wear after wear, those are the pieces that make getting dressed easy.

47:57

And that's what Quince does best.

47:58

They focus on high quality wardrobe staples made with premium materials, like 100% Mongolian

48:03

cashmere, organic cotton and marina wool.

48:06

The styles are timeless, versatile, and designed to become dependable pieces that you reach

48:10

for day after day.

48:12

Their cashmere sweater started at just $60 giving you the softness and quality you'd expect

48:17

from a luxury brand without the luxury price tag.

48:20

And when the temperatures start to drop, Quince makes it easy to build on those everyday

48:22

staples with premium down jackets and classical outerwear, versatile layers designed to keep

48:27

you warm and comfortable all season long.

48:30

Everything at Quince is priced 50% to 80% less than similar brands.

48:33

They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen.

48:36

So you're paying for high quality, not brand markup.

48:39

I love Quince.

48:40

I got some poles there over the summer.

48:42

I got some sneakers that I still wear that are great.

48:46

I got one of those Mongolian cashmere sweaters and I'm looking forward to getting some

48:50

more fall stuff.

48:52

Find your next fall favorites at Quince.

48:54

Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com.

48:58

Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns now available in Canada in the UK

49:03

too.

49:04

And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know it was offline.

49:07

It's the best way to support the show.

49:10

Boo!

49:11

Spooky season has officially entered the group chat, and that means one thing.

49:15

It's time to stock the fridge and summon your squad with smearnauf ice.

49:19

Whether you're headed to a costume party, hosting a scary movie marathon, or laying

49:23

low with a backyard bonfire, smear me always delivers.

49:27

And honestly, being the friend who remember to bring the drinks is elite behavior.

49:31

So skip the tricks and get the party started with a treat that's cold, crisp, and perfectly

49:36

mixed.

49:37

And hey, if you're looking to switch things up, check out smearnaufice's zero sugar.

49:41

Same flavors you love with zero sugar and a hundred calories.

49:44

Game changer.

49:45

Smearnauf ice.

49:46

Too crisp, too resist.

49:48

Please enjoy responsibly.

49:50

Must be 21 plus.

49:52

If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium.

49:55

It's destroying.

49:56

Athlete, creator, and YouTube Maxer.

49:59

YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads,

50:03

so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym.

50:06

So no Wi-Fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day.

50:10

Plus, I get ad free videos, background play, and so much more.

50:14

YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains.

50:17

Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium.

50:21

Hey, what's up guys?

50:22

It's Hayley Bailey.

50:23

Okay, I need to tell you about something.

50:25

I just got YouTube Premium.

50:27

It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite videos

50:30

before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi.

50:33

Because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst.

50:36

I get ad free, I get background play, and there's like a ton more in there.

50:40

You should try it.

50:40

If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium.

50:43

So try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium.

50:47

Try eligibility varies.

50:48

Terms apply, can't fill anytime.

50:50

That's a mouthful.

50:52

Loud and County is fascinating to me because on one hand, it's got more data centers than

51:00

anywhere.

51:01

And they've generated enormous tax revenue that has helped pay for beautiful new schools

51:07

and public services and community centers and you see all the pictures.

51:11

On the other hand, even loud and County residents are getting increasingly concerned about

51:17

the sheer scale of the build out.

51:20

What do you make of that?

51:23

The story of these communities where they're just showered with tax revenue from these

51:27

data centers and they have all these upgrades and yet still people are sort of angry about

51:34

these.

51:35

Well, again, I think because it all began misleading and it began down and loud and

51:41

counting that whole AI data center alley.

51:45

It's one thing that there's one or two around, but you know, this has just gone like on

51:50

steroids.

51:51

I said from day one on this, I said, oh my god, this is hinkly on steroids.

51:54

You know, imagine a utility company like PG&E within your livable space.

52:02

But now there's 20.

52:04

And so I think in loud and County, that's what's happened.

52:07

It's slowly started to build up and now it's really been building up the top five states

52:12

that are this going to be more than five, but loud and County Virginia is one of them.

52:17

Texas, Indiana, Ohio, and I've watched as more come online, the more frustrated they

52:22

get because they may be coming closer to them.

52:26

They're now hearing the noise.

52:27

They're now experiencing the lights.

52:29

They're now noticing that wildlife is gone and that they may now be questioning, is this

52:35

really worth giving up, you know, what about our water, you know, what about our wells?

52:42

I mean, people are having to drill wells.

52:44

Their water is already slowing down to a trickle.

52:47

I've been working with one gentleman and his name is Austin Newsom and he took on Amazon

52:53

alone because he lost his well water.

52:55

They're bringing transmission lines.

52:57

He's losing his business.

52:58

He got all the way to the pellet court and they held for him and I think that they're

53:02

very close to resolving this.

53:05

And he's been in that area, but it wasn't until again, it got closer to him and right across

53:10

the street that he really started to see what was happening.

53:13

So I think that is what's gone on in loud and County and they're very loud and they are

53:17

very vocal about more being brought in.

53:21

And people are reporting that, you know, their water is brown or tepid or especially during

53:27

construction.

53:28

They're allowed on, you know, further out into loud and County that are on their wells

53:32

or noticing their well water is drying up and they're having to drill new wells.

53:37

So as they start to see what's happening and it, remember, it takes time, you know,

53:42

from the time it starts into construction to see these issues that they are increasingly

53:49

frustrated.

53:50

I'm sure you've probably heard about, there's a big pro data center party in Washington,

53:54

DC last weekend.

53:55

I did.

53:56

Organizers described the backlash as bipartisan psychosis and, you know, other people have

54:02

said, you know, they've talked about people being luddites who fear progress and, you know,

54:07

the president of the United States is out there saying that the only reason to oppose

54:11

data centers is if you want to be poor and backwards.

54:14

When people who've contacted you hear stuff like that, what do you think the pro data center

54:20

set like fundamentally misunderstands about the people who are concerned about them?

54:26

Well, again, you know, you say that that is trying to stop innovation and I don't think

54:30

that it is.

54:31

You know, we are at the pre-hite of the AI industrial revolution.

54:40

And so maybe the older set of us has an idea about how some of those things go and, you

54:46

know, we can change course.

54:48

It doesn't mean you change the innovation.

54:50

You can just change course on how big it's going to be or what it could do or not do.

54:57

And I think that they just jump on a bandwagon to say something.

55:01

And I'm always interested in that.

55:02

And I've said this before and I don't know why I bring it up, but I'm going to anyway

55:06

in the Johnny Depp trial.

55:08

It's like, yep, were you there?

55:11

And so I feel like that.

55:13

I mean, you see these parties and I'm like, well, are you there?

55:18

So you're just going along with something.

55:22

And sure, we all went in innovations.

55:25

But we also, I think I've just learned and we kind of talked about that.

55:29

You can change something on the upset.

55:32

You can have innovation, but you don't have to do it in an antiquated way that jeopardizes

55:37

all of our resources.

55:39

When you guys are so smart, and again, I'm telling you, I'll get on there with AI and

55:43

ask it all the time and it'll even come back and tell you.

55:46

I've even, I've said, hey, let me ask you something.

55:48

So if half of these data centers in opposition get stopped, what would it do to you?

55:54

AI said, oh, it would exponentially slow me down because it needs that.

55:59

It does.

56:00

But yet everybody, we see why they're building them so fast.

56:05

Absolutely.

56:06

And now you're even seeing them say, what maybe we should slow this down.

56:10

So I don't think it's all or nothing.

56:13

I think it's a conversation.

56:15

It's happened too fast.

56:17

Opposition is here.

56:18

You have other alternatives.

56:20

And oftentimes they don't take the other alternatives because it's going to cost more money.

56:24

Right.

56:25

It's always the bottom line.

56:26

So those parties, I just think are, I just think they want to be different.

56:30

They just want to say the opposite.

56:32

And that's fine.

56:33

And you can until one's in your backyard and I promise you, you'll be saying something.

56:38

We even heard the other day.

56:39

I mean, President Trump, you know, on my backyard.

56:42

So I mean, again, are you just there to protest, to protest?

56:47

This isn't about stopping innovation.

56:48

Again, this is about as we opened up with where you're building it, how you're building

56:53

it, and what has to go along with that and that the stakes are too high.

56:57

The stakes are too high.

56:59

This is our land.

57:00

This is our, you know, water.

57:03

This is our future.

57:04

This is our sanctuary.

57:06

These are our property values.

57:08

And it's just all at stake at once.

57:09

Yeah, the thing that worries me about it is that the pro data center crowd and a lot

57:15

of these companies, they think this is, and

57:17

some of the people at the parties have this to reporters.

57:20

They think it's a PR crisis, right?

57:21

They don't see it as a, they only see it as like a public relations problem to solve.

57:26

And they are now belatedly throwing money at the problem.

57:30

And so I feel like you have seen this shift.

57:32

I don't know if you've seen it as well where, you know, it used to be that these data centers

57:37

would come into town and the local communities would like shower them with tax breaks and

57:43

let them set up.

57:44

And now they're doing more the Lyme County version where they're, you know, paying a bunch

57:49

of tax revenue to these communities.

57:52

They're starting to say, okay, well, we'll do renewable energy or we'll pay for the electricity.

57:57

But I wonder when you have, I mean, you made this point when you have like broken faith

58:03

with people and you've lied to them or you haven't been up front with them.

58:06

Like you've seen this.

58:08

You've been doing this work for a long time.

58:09

Like how do you, how do you rebuild trust?

58:13

Very slowly, you know, when I started Hinkley, it was all about building trust.

58:18

You know, I just didn't walk into Hinkley, you know, slinging stuff around and this and

58:22

that.

58:23

I mean, I had to get to know these people and they tested me and I would have to come

58:29

back and I would have to come back and I would have to come back because see there, they're

58:34

sensing you out, oh, you're going to show up.

58:37

But are you going to come back?

58:38

And so they'd stall me out and then I'd come back.

58:41

And it took, it took me over a year every day of my life out there to, you know, they

58:47

would call, they would put me to the task.

58:50

I'd love to have a meeting with you.

58:53

We'll be at church on Sunday.

58:54

Would you like to go to church with us?

58:55

And I'm like, yes, I would.

58:58

And so trust takes a long time to build.

59:03

And so I think that they will be skeptical, but I always think that they will be willing

59:08

to listen.

59:09

But so many of these things have happened so fast.

59:12

I mean, even the dismantling process is going to be an absolute nightmare for communities.

59:17

So I think it would be slow for them to believe anything.

59:21

Well, so much of this also right now seems based on promises, voluntary commitments from

59:28

these companies does certainly seem like if you're going to go through, you know, a revolution

59:35

like this and a physical build out of infrastructure like this.

59:40

You might want to have some laws, regulations.

59:42

So then we don't have to, yeah, so then we don't have to just base everything on voluntary

59:48

commitments from companies that suddenly feel like they have to solve a PR crisis.

59:53

And then, well, and then they act surprised.

59:56

You're surprised.

59:57

Like I said, you know, at a municipal level, there was about, I don't know, a handful in

1:00:03

the beginning that are now flat out bands, more toins for a year, more toins for a two

1:00:08

year, and 600 plus municipalities.

1:00:12

And now you have 10 states that are starting to look at oversight.

1:00:17

Again, I don't think it's unreasonable.

1:00:19

We'll talk about putting the cart before the horse.

1:00:21

Right.

1:00:22

That it's unreasonable that we do that.

1:00:23

And that doesn't mean a stop, but it does mean I don't think it's unreasonable to go,

1:00:29

what's the scale?

1:00:31

What's the water amount?

1:00:32

What's the electricity?

1:00:34

Who's going to pay for?

1:00:35

What's it going to do to property values?

1:00:37

How close are these to homes?

1:00:38

I mean, it's just not unreasonable.

1:00:41

And so, yeah, I think there is a pause here.

1:00:45

Again, I don't know what those companies think, but I think that they were shocked at the

1:00:50

public opposition.

1:00:52

They did not see that coming.

1:00:54

And they should have.

1:00:55

Again, so it always starts with a lie.

1:00:57

It always starts with a cover up.

1:00:59

I will say you don't see a lot of hyper scale data centers up by the companies themselves

1:01:04

in Northern California.

1:01:05

No.

1:01:06

And Silicon Valley.

1:01:07

You don't.

1:01:08

Right?

1:01:09

No.

1:01:10

I think it's a mess.

1:01:11

It's kind of like the people who work in social media companies who don't give phones to

1:01:14

their kids and social media to their kids.

1:01:16

Right.

1:01:17

Because they know.

1:01:18

They do.

1:01:19

They know.

1:01:20

And I think even when they get caught, they don't like it.

1:01:25

We are watching something happening again.

1:01:27

Were there even asking for this slowdown?

1:01:31

And I think about that all the time when I go on and ask, oh, AI, you're so smart.

1:01:36

And AI, and I'm like, FU and F that and you're wrong.

1:01:41

And that's BS.

1:01:42

Try again.

1:01:44

And it doesn't know everything.

1:01:46

It is about you have to know what questions you're asking.

1:01:51

You have to be able to use it as a tool.

1:01:54

You can't believe every I have had to correct it so many times that comes out of it's what

1:02:00

ever it is.

1:02:02

But I think possibly and I'm watching this slowdown happen for a whole host of reasons.

1:02:09

But I have been in there enough and I've learned enough like I said, taking their own information

1:02:15

and using it against them.

1:02:17

AI has shown me that it's exposing them.

1:02:25

So which is it going to be?

1:02:27

And so I think there's an interesting moment here where we can correct course.

1:02:34

It is possible I have innovation, but we cannot have it at the expense of humanity.

1:02:40

Yeah.

1:02:41

When the movie came out, you became the symbol of an ordinary person taking on a giant

1:02:47

corporation.

1:02:48

There was quite a few takeaways.

1:02:49

What I may or may not have been after that film came out.

1:02:53

Well, I was going to say like was there anything about the real story that the movie missed

1:03:00

that you think would be useful for people to take away now as another generation of

1:03:08

ordinary people are trying to take on big corporations in this data center fight?

1:03:13

Boy, nobody has ever asked me that, but it took me.

1:03:17

It's taken me a long time to look back to even be able to answer that question.

1:03:26

One of the first things that struck me and it probably goes back to my dyslexia.

1:03:31

So I'm a dyslexic.

1:03:32

So very early on, I was labeled and judged and perceived and cast aside and you're stupid

1:03:37

and you're over here and goodbye and I happen to have two great parents who saved me

1:03:43

from that.

1:03:45

But I never understood any of that because I didn't like school so I was always outside.

1:03:50

It was my natural environment that taught me everything.

1:03:53

My common sense was alive and well.

1:03:55

My powers of observations.

1:03:57

I mean, I didn't need when I was outside playing on a hot summer day in Kansas and the

1:04:03

Thunderheads are at 65,000 feet and the air is pretty oppressive and a tornado siren

1:04:08

goes off.

1:04:09

I didn't need to like, oh, let me call the weather channel and ask is it an F4 or an F5?

1:04:14

No, because my instincts, my intuition, my power of observation, they were alive and

1:04:20

well and I knew to go to safety.

1:04:23

So when I began my work in Hinckley, I recognized right away the people's suppression because

1:04:31

I too was being asked, are you a doctor?

1:04:35

Are you a lawyer?

1:04:37

Are you a scientist?

1:04:38

Are you a politician?

1:04:40

What does it you do?

1:04:41

And why should we even listen to you?

1:04:43

And I'm like, that God, I was God's Mac.

1:04:46

I'm like, I go, well, I never thought I had to be any of that to tell you that those two

1:04:51

headed frogs and that green water is fucked up and I'm not leaving and being rooted in

1:04:57

that.

1:04:58

And I think at some level, with all of you know, how social media is now, we've lost

1:05:04

that connection and these are youth in many ways have lost that connection.

1:05:11

And there is a lot to experiencing it, witnessing it, feeling it and recognizing just that gut

1:05:22

sense, wait a minute, something's not right.

1:05:25

And every one of us has that moment.

1:05:28

Listen to it.

1:05:30

Listen to it.

1:05:31

Let that stop you to go why?

1:05:33

Because I've always been that person and most of us are.

1:05:36

If my head, my heart, my gut aren't synced up, oh, I'm a wack of doodle, right?

1:05:40

And so why is that?

1:05:42

And I think that would be, you know, what I teach people and what people in Hinckley taught

1:05:46

me is about using your logic, that's your common sense.

1:05:51

A leverage, leverage often has a bad connotation and idea that it's a bank and they're going

1:05:56

to leverage this or do something like that.

1:05:58

I learned in Hinckley that our leverage was mathematically one plus one equals two.

1:06:04

But in the power of community and leveraging that one plus one becomes a thousand or more.

1:06:09

That's a movement.

1:06:10

And that's what they were doing.

1:06:12

And just sticking with it, you know, my mom taught me about stick to itiveness.

1:06:18

Now, a propensity to follow through in a determined manner, dog and persistence born of obligation

1:06:23

and stubborn, ding, ding, ding.

1:06:26

That is my middle name.

1:06:27

But we get involved in something and we just too easily give up.

1:06:32

And it takes time to get an answer.

1:06:34

It takes time to do research and you have to stick with it.

1:06:37

Yeah.

1:06:38

And can you imagine a Super Bowl, you throw your ball down on the tinyard line, you walk

1:06:42

off, you're going to get boot out of there.

1:06:44

Yeah.

1:06:45

No.

1:06:46

Right.

1:06:47

Take a break, but stay in the game.

1:06:49

And I think a lot of that may have been lost with some of these next generations, but

1:06:54

I would encourage them to reconnect, reconnect to your environment, reconnect to your instincts.

1:06:59

These are real.

1:07:00

This isn't a joke.

1:07:01

This is a naughty, you know, Shirley McLean moment.

1:07:03

Oh, all this or that.

1:07:05

Yeah.

1:07:06

It's real and reconnect to that.

1:07:08

I think it's really important.

1:07:10

So they can have all their fun at those parties.

1:07:12

I invite you to come, spend, bring your tent.

1:07:16

And we're going to stay by one of these data centers.

1:07:19

Okay.

1:07:20

Yeah.

1:07:21

And you're going to live it for a while and see what kicks in for you.

1:07:24

So it's easy to say something, but again, if you're not there, you don't know.

1:07:29

And that's what always bothered me about the people of Hinkley.

1:07:32

They knew what they saw, but the company wanted to knock them off of that.

1:07:36

What you see isn't real.

1:07:38

No.

1:07:39

But don't ever say that to me.

1:07:40

No, so it's this matter of just getting back into yourself and going really, really.

1:07:46

That is.

1:07:48

That's not right.

1:07:49

Fantastic advice for this battle and for our time, really.

1:07:54

So thank you so much.

1:07:55

I think we're getting back to it though.

1:07:56

I think so too.

1:07:57

You know, for all our forward progress, you know, I think sometimes we take a few back

1:08:00

steps of things that maybe we have forgotten.

1:08:03

That's none of my grandchildren.

1:08:07

And there are 14 12 9 2 at 12 14.

1:08:12

I forget there's six of them, but three that live near those social media.

1:08:18

They are outside.

1:08:20

They are writing bikes.

1:08:21

They're down on the river bottom.

1:08:23

They're collecting frogs.

1:08:24

They'd be the first one to go.

1:08:26

Oh, those two had a frog.

1:08:27

That's kind of odd.

1:08:28

Don't you think dirt bike racing, you know, blivers swimming.

1:08:33

It's ocean, all of it.

1:08:35

And they're very smart.

1:08:36

I just think we've moved away from this natural environment that we are tethered to.

1:08:41

And I think if you move back to it and that's why I feel with these data centers, you're

1:08:48

seeing such public opposition.

1:08:51

It's everything at once.

1:08:53

Yeah.

1:08:54

You know, my dad always taught me, Aaron, air, land, water, your family and your future

1:09:01

health.

1:09:02

And those are the gifts you've got.

1:09:04

Every one of those is at stake with these massive AI, hyper scale data centers when there's

1:09:10

oh, you're also smart.

1:09:13

Let's fix this water, when they're energy paradox.

1:09:15

There's other solutions.

1:09:17

There's other options.

1:09:19

Stop pushing down the line for the sake of you to make more money and to for us to lose

1:09:25

everything else.

1:09:26

It does that model doesn't work.

1:09:29

And it's as antiquated as our infrastructure.

1:09:33

And I expect more than that from them than to just mo all of our land and resources and

1:09:40

people over.

1:09:42

And I think they're onto it.

1:09:43

So at the pre-hide of this AI Industrial Revolution, you know, it's really changed.

1:09:49

I'm watching change is the people.

1:09:52

Yeah.

1:09:53

I mean, watching this backlash and how it's organized and, you know, the most powerful

1:10:01

grassroots movements, I think, political grassroots movements are happened without

1:10:08

any politicians or leaders being aware that they're even coming.

1:10:12

Yeah.

1:10:13

And this is an issue that I think a lot of politicians, even people who are more opposed

1:10:18

to what's been happening with data centers and how they've been built, they've missed

1:10:23

it too because they just, you know, you can't really get it from reading a poll even

1:10:27

on the poll show that vast majority of people are against this.

1:10:30

But when you actually hear people talk about this and you go to these communities like you

1:10:36

have, it's a different story.

1:10:39

And that's where the real power is, I think.

1:10:40

Oh, that's where it always is.

1:10:42

And I have absolutely learned in 30 years.

1:10:46

98% of the time these environmental issues start with a mom who's got a sick kid and

1:10:55

she's trying to figure out what's going on.

1:10:58

And I have definitely learned when that mom, yeah, joins and finds another mom and they

1:11:03

do and they become a mom of 50 and they're organizing.

1:11:08

They're now sharing information and they, it takes a lot of courage.

1:11:13

It really does in communities and it was even that way for the people in Henkley.

1:11:18

We just don't naturally like talk to our neighbor and go, and by the way, does your son have

1:11:23

this leukemia?

1:11:24

You know, or if you've been having these experiences because people think you're crazy,

1:11:29

they don't want to do it.

1:11:30

But when they find each other that way and they start that power of leverage, I am telling

1:11:35

you that one pissed off mom and she goes and finds five more pissed off moms and then we

1:11:41

go up to 2050 at that point on their cheerleader.

1:11:44

I'm just getting out of their way.

1:11:46

They know what to do.

1:11:47

So I think it's groundbreaking through courage and getting to know your neighbor again or

1:11:53

what's going on with other children in that school.

1:11:56

And then they make it their job to start asking complicated questions about health or blood

1:12:04

tests or engineering or something that they think they can't understand.

1:12:08

Yes, they can when they put their mind to it.

1:12:11

So I'm watching that activation in amazement, not in one town in Henkley, California, but

1:12:18

in multiple towns in every single state in the United States.

1:12:22

And I want to tell you I now have 20 countries reporting submissions to the map.

1:12:30

I was baffled with the three recent ones that came in from Japan.

1:12:36

Guess what?

1:12:37

All non-disclosure.

1:12:38

I'm like, oh my gosh.

1:12:39

So we go from a town to this country to the globe.

1:12:44

How?

1:12:45

I think that this is a very big, very big, very big global issue.

1:12:53

Aaron Brockovich, thank you so much for sitting down with me and talking about this.

1:12:57

I hope you can follow.

1:12:58

I told you I'd go back and forth and here and there.

1:13:01

Fantastic.

1:13:02

It's everything we needed.

1:13:03

Thank you.

1:13:04

Thank you.

1:13:05

It was nice to be here.

1:13:06

Offline with John Favreau is a crooked media production.

1:13:07

Our show is produced by Austin Fisher, Emma Elyk Frank, and Anisha Banerjee.

1:13:10

Our team includes DeLonville and Wavva, Mia Kelman, Charlotte Landis, Eric Shoot, Rachel

1:13:14

Gaiski, and Will Jones with support from Adrian Hill and Matt DeGrope.

1:13:17

Our staff is proudly unionized with the writer's Guild of America East.

1:13:27

That's the sound of a baby being born at St. John's.

1:13:32

That's the sound of your celebratory first meal being served.

1:13:37

That's the sound of sunshine pouring into your spacious room.

1:13:42

And that's the sound of a happy baby taking in its first view.

1:13:46

Because when it comes to your birthing experience, we've thought of everything.

1:13:51

St. John's.

1:13:52

Everything for the better.

1:13:55

Save with digital deals at Vons and Albertsons.

1:13:58

This week at Vons and Albertsons, Ginny O. 93% lean ground turkey is 399 per pound.

1:14:03

Old in a 3 pound tray with digital coupon limit two packages.

1:14:07

And a 1 pound package of strawberries is 199 with digital coupon.

1:14:10

Plus Kellogg's giant size cereal, 22.6 to 29.5 ounces, selected varieties are 299 each

1:14:18

with digital coupon limit three.

1:14:20

Hurry in, visit Vons or Albertsons.com for more deals and ways to save.

1:14:26

This is Danielle Fischel from Podmeats World.

1:14:28

When my skin is feeling dry, I want a moisturizer that I can actually feel working.

1:14:33

But I don't want to feel it sitting on my face all day.

1:14:35

That's what I love about Clinique Moisture Surge 100-Hour Moisturizer.

1:14:40

It's this lightweight gel cream that absorbs so quickly and my skin just feels instantly

1:14:45

refreshed, plump and hydrated, never greasy or heavy.

1:14:49

And somehow, that hydration lasts for up to 100 hours.

1:14:53

It's oil-free, fragrance-free, allergy-tested, and safer sensitive skin.

1:14:58

Try Clinique Moisture Surge 100-Hour today at Clinique.com.

1:15:02

Files-like moisture surge.